Chapter 132: Buried Beneath The Water: The Death of Olivia Lone Bear
In 2017, Olivia Lone Bear disappeared from the Fort Berthold Reservation in North Dakota. Months later, her truck was discovered submerged in a reservoir, but the answers never surfaced. As the investigation stalled, the story of a missing mother and the community that searched tirelessly for her became part of a larger, devastating pattern: the crisis of missing and murdered Indigenous women whose cases remain unsolved, yet refuse to be forgotten.
If you have any information regarding the death of Olivia Lone Bear, you are urged to contact the FBI at: 1-800-CALL-FBI, or you can submit a tip at fbi.tips.gov
Check out Adventures with Purpose
Connect with us on Social Media!
You can find us at:
Instagram: @bookofthedeadpod
X: @bkofthedeadpod
Facebook: The Book of the Dead Podcast
TikTok: Bookofthedeadpod
Or visit our website at www.botdpod.com
Featuring a Promo for True Crime Connections:
True Crime Connections is a survivor-led podcast where stories of abuse, trauma, and resilience are shared with raw honesty and purpose.
Listen here
Body found in submerged truck believed to be missing mother of five. (2018, August 3). NBC News. https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/missing-in-america/fbi-confident-body-found-submerged-truck-belongs-missing-mother-olivia-n897546BREAKING: New information in Olivia Lone Bear case. (2019, November 20). KX News. https://www.kxnet.com/news/local-news/breaking-new-information-in-olivia-lone-bear-case/Dura, J. (2018a, February 3). Searchers comb Bismarck for missing woman as volunteer effort expands. The Jamestown Sun, A4.Dura, J. (2018b, February 4). Bureau of Indian Affairs takes lead in Lone Bear Case. The Bismarck Tribune, 1.Dura, J., & Emerson, B. (2018a, December 28). Lone Bear case awaits answers. The Bismarck Tribune, A1.Dura, J., & Emerson, B. (2018b, December 29). 14 months after North Dakota woman was last seen alive, family and tribes await answers. The Dickinson Press, A3.Emerson, B. (2019, April 9). Stenejhem: Lone Bear report of death exempt from open records. The Jamestown Sun, B4.Emerson, B., & Dura, J. (2019, August 2). One year later, no answers from FBI about death of Olivia Lone Bear. Grand Forks Herald, B2.Family frustrated by lack of search efforts in Native America woman Olivia Lone Bear’s disappearance. (2017, December 11). NBC News. https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/missing-in-america/family-frustrated-lack-search-efforts-native-america-woman-olivia-lone-n828561Hopkins, R. (2018, September 11). When the missing and murdered Indigenous women crisis hits home. Teen Vogue. https://www.teenvogue.com/story/when-missing-and-murdered-indigenous-women-epidemic-hits-homeKeeler, J., & Keeler, J. (2024, January 24). ‘No crime scene’: The search for Olivia Lone Bear. High Country News. https://www.hcn.org/issues/50-12/tribal-affairs-no-crime-scene-the-search-for-olivia-lone-bear/Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Relatives (MMIWR) | NIWRC. (n.d.). https://www.niwrc.org/mmiwr-awarenessObituary for Olivia Keri Lone Bear at Langhans Funeral Homes, Inc. (2018, August 5). https://www.langhansfuneralhome.com/obituary/olivia-lone-bearOgden, E. (2018, January 2). $5000 more reward offered in search of Olivia Lone Bear. The Dickinson Press, 2.OLIVIA LONE BEAR. (n.d.). FBI. https://www.fbi.gov/wanted/seeking-info/olivia-lone-bearSkurzewski, J. (2019a, July 31). Investigation continues into death, disappearance of Olivia Lone Bear. https://www.kfyrtv.com. https://www.kfyrtv.com/content/news/Timeline-of-events-in-Olivia-Lone-Bear-investigation-513457331.htmlSkurzewski, J. (2019b, November 20). Feds meet with Lone Bear family, offer reward for information. https://www.kfyrtv.com. https://www.kfyrtv.com/content/news/Feds-meet-with-Lone-Bear-family-offer-reward-for-information-565233562.htmlSuspicious death: Olivia Lone Bear | New Town, ND | Uncovered. (n.d.). https://uncovered.com/cases/olivia-lone-bearThe Associated Press. (2019, November 21). Native woman found in Fort Berthold Lake was belted in. Rapid City Journal, A5.Wigginton, C. (2018, July 9). Frustration with investigation mounts. The Bismarck Tribune, A5.
If you enjoyed the episode, consider leaving a review or rating! It helps more than you know!
If you have a case suggestion, or want attention brought to a loved one's case, email me at bookofthedeadpod@gmail.com with Case Suggestion in the subject line.
Stay safe, stay curious, and stay vigilant.
0:01 Every story has a beginning, but not everyone has an ending. In the shadows of headlines and buried police reports lay the voices of the missing, the murdered, and the forgotten, waiting to be heard and have their stories told. This is the Book of the Dead, a true crime podcast where we remember forgotten victims of heinous crimes, reopen cold cases, re visit haunting disappearances, and uncover the truths buried beneath the years of silence. I'm your host, Courtney Liso, and every week we turn to another chapter, one victim, one mystery, one step Closer to justice. Brought to you by Darkast Network INDEEP Podcasts with the twist.
1:11 Have you ever wondered how in the hell did I get here? You are not alone. My podcast is called True Crime Connections with an advocacy podcast where I talk with survivors of toxic relationships, abuse of marriages. We all have one thing in common. How in that hell did we get here? And how do we get out? How do we find our self worth again? Well, if you feel that way, come check out my podcast, because not only do you get actionable steps to take to help you take your life back, but you can listen to how others have dealt with their own situations, including addiction, suicidal ideation, and low self worth and respect.
2:04 We can get you on the right track. Make sure to check out True Crime Connections. See you there, Hello, Hello, Welcome to the next chapter in the Book of the Dead. Over the last few days, I have spent a significant amount of time watching videos from Adventures with Purpose, primarily because one of my best friends loves to watch them. For those that don't know, Adventures with Purpose is an underwater sonar search and recovery dive team. It was founded by Jared Lasik and from their website, since December of twenty nineteen, they have located over forty missing loved ones underwater in their vehicles. The organization offers their services free of charge to families and law enforcement, funding their efforts through donations from the public.
2:57 They do incredible work, going above and beyond to bring closure to families, and that's in part what inspired this episode. When a young Indigenous woman seemingly vanishes after a night out at a bar, her family spends months desperately searching for her, as jurisdictional issues and miscommunications hindered law enforcement's efforts to find her themselves. When the car she borrowed is found at the bottom of Lake Sakakuweya, the investigation pivots to figure out what exactly happened the night she went missing and who could have been responsible. This is the death of Olivia Loanbear. Olivia Carey Loanbearer, whose Hidatsa name was Cedar Woman, was born on October eleventh, nineteen eighty five, to Iris Sherman Forbear and Harley Text Loanbear.
3:51 She was a member of the Mandan Hidatsa and Arikara nation also known as the Three Affiliated Tribes and Mahahati or Dripping Dirty Clan, and she also identified as a member of the Spirit Lake tribe. Olivia grew up with a large family. She had two sisters, Erin and Marlis, as well as five brothers, Melichi, Harley, Houston, Matthew, and Joy, and she loved spending time with them and going on adventures. Throughout her school years, she made a lot of friends and not only did she excel in her classes, but Olivia loved being involved in athletics, playing basketball, volleyball, and running cross country track. She did move around a lot, starting high school in Newtown, North Dakota, before moving to Montana and later Washington State when she entered her junior year in two thousand and three. That year, she also gave birth to her first child, a little girl, and so she could raise her daughter, she transitioned to homeschooling and an independent studies programmed in order to obtain her diploma.
5:00 By two thousand and five, Olivia would suffer a devastating loss after the death of her second child at eight months old, and she transitioned to a more nomadic lifestyle, going between Welpinit in Washington and Newtown, before finally settling back home there on the Fort Bertholed Reservation for good in two thousand and nine. She built a life for her children, going on to have four more, and she worked hard, taking on various jobs at the Forebears Casino and launch. Her favorite position was working as a live games dealer, and she also picked up ships at the Edgewater golf Course in Legion. Olivia was an incredibly hard worker and wanted to give her babies, who were her world, the best life possible, but she also loved to have fun with her friends and family. She was always ready to go out and play poker or golf, and she loved a good concert. She was known to be incredibly adventurous and loved to go on spontaneous trips and spend as much time outdoors with her loved ones when the weather permitted as possible. Described by her family as vibrant and outgoing, intelligent and loving, she spent many days just spending as much time as she could with her family, taking on a large role in caring for her father and her grandfather. By twenty seventeen, when this case begins, things were a bit hard for thirty two year old Olivia, and she was focusing most of her time on taking
6:31 care of her children by this point, all under the age of fourteen. According to an interview, her brother Matthew, gave a dateline she was in between jobs, so that's all she did take care of them. She stayed at the house and cooked dinner at night and got the kids to school in the morning. Matthew recalled that while things were difficult for his sister, she was in good spirits and didn't appear to be under any real stress. She was her usual outume going self, going about her day to day life, taking care of her family, By this point, she was living with her father and children at a home on the edge of the Fort berth Told Reservation, and nothing was amiss with her, which made the events that came after all the more devastating for her family. On October twenty fourth, twenty seventeen, according to an article for Kfgo, Olivia had plans to go out with her friends to a bar. She told one of her children she would be home later, and she headed to the Sportsman's Bar in Newtown. Later that evening, and the exact time is unknown. Olivia leaves the bar and gets into a blue twenty eleven Chevrolet Silverado twenty five hundred HDLT with a dented tailgate and a silver toolbox visible in the back. According to the Dickinson Press, Olivia had gotten into the driver's seat, but her brother, according to Dateline, was asked not to comment on whether or not she had left with anybody. According to an article
8:02 for High Country, the truck was lent to her by a friend, Jim Hoffanky, who confirmed that he had spoken to Olivia that day. He said he lent her his car whenever she needed it, and on the twenty fourth she had texted him and mentioned doing laundry. Haffankey said he went to the house to drop up some groceries, but no one was home and when he later returned, Olivia was not there. It is believed that Olivia returned to her home at some point that evening, though, as her phone and her wallet were in her room, as well as the clothing she had been wearing two sportsmans that night, but she wasn't seen by anybody in her house.
8:43 After two days of not being able to get into contact with his daughter, Harley Lonebear called the tribal police to report her missing. However, the police were not quick to investigate, taking another three days to take action or issue a statewide alert. Matthew said quote The Maha Nation Police did not act on the missing person's report until the following Monday, and news couldn't report and put it on air until the Tribal Police department filed a police report. One of the critical issues at the very start of this investigation was a lack of evidence. There were no signs of foul play, no trace of where she could have gone, and no one reported anything suspicious. While a witness had come forward, according to the Rapid City Journal, who said that Olivia had texted her on the night she disappeared, saying she had been at a bonfire and she was planning on going mudding. If she was with anyone or going anywhere specific was not mentioned, so it wasn't very much to go on. Detective Sam Lincoln of the Three affiliated Tribes police department told Dateline that in the first two weeks of the initial investigation, they had combed through the waterways in the area searching for her, but absolutely nothing was found. Also searching were Olivia's brothers and uncles, and they took their ATVs out to cover more area, but with hundreds of thousands of acres to cover,
10:13 search efforts were difficult without a clear direction to look in. Not only was the investigation hindered due to having very little to go on, Olivia's family was left frustrated by a lack of communication from the tribal police. Allegedly, it took five weeks for investigators to come speak to the family after Olivia had been reported missing, and they were left in the dark for far longer than what anyone would consider acceptable. Matthew said, quote, they should have come to talk to us right when she was reported missing. We don't even know who the lead investigators are. We try to be civil and work with them, but there's a lack of transparency from them. Additionally, they were allegedly not willing to verify tips that were coming in. Matthew claimed that someone had spotted hoff Henky's truck, or at least one that looked like it, but because the tipster cannot provide a color of the vehicle or its license plate number, no one from the police department went out and spoke to this tipster to see what they knew.
11:17 The family had also asked police to search the on Star system to try and locate the Silverado, but questions of whether or not this had been done when unanswered. By December, the Lone Bear family was vocal in their disappointment with police. While they acknowledged that original search efforts by them were good and they were proactive in looking for Olivia once they had started, that drive that should have been consistent had lost its power. At a press conference, Lisa Yellowbird Chase three Affiliate Tribes member and the founder of Sawnish Scouts, an organization that conducts searches for missing people, especially those in North Dakota's Indian and oil countries said, quote, don't wait for law enforcement because as people have this false sense of security that when you file a missing person report that all of the officers and detectives jump in their cars and run all over the place looking for this person. Lysa and the Sano Scouts joined Matthew in launching a large scale search to find Olivia and bring her home, setting up search camps and organizing volunteers and search parties set out to try and cover as much as possible, using drones to try and find the Silverado, but they were consistently left frustrated when nothing was found.
12:31 Also active in assisting the family was North Dakota Senator Heidi hate Camp, who was vocal in her advocation for crimes against Indigenous women. According to NBC, she had introduced Savannah's Act into legislation the same month that Olivia disappeared, in an effort to combat the epidemic of violence against Indigenous women and girls. This was done in response to the murder of twenty two year old Savannah Lafontaine gray Wynd, who was brutally murdered and her baby had been ripped from her womb two months before Olivia went missing in twenty nineteen, when this act was presented at that year's legislative session, Spirit Lake Nation Tribal Chairwoman Mara Pearson said in her address of the two cases that they quote forced local, state, and national attention to the fact that Indigenous women are missing and murdered at rates far exceeding national averages, and all too often justice salutes the families in such cases. Unfortunately, cases like this are and at the time of Olivia's disappearance, were all too familiar for Indigenous women and their families. In twenty seventeen alone, Native women made up one point eight percent of missing persons cases in the FBI's national databases. Indigenous women are also more likely to experience sexual violence by non natives. In twenty sixteen, according to the National Crime Information Center, there were fifty seven hundred reports of missing and murdered Indigenous
14:01 women in just the United States alone. Again, those numbers are specifically from the time of Olivia's disappearance. The numbers for twenty twenty five are alarmingly much higher, according to the National Indigenous Women's Resource Center, Quote, American, Indian and Alaska Native women experience a murder rate ten times higher than the national average. More than four and five American, Indian and Alaska Natives, or eighty four point three percent, have experienced violence in their lifetime. Fifty six point one percent have experienced sexual violence, fifty five point five percent have experienced physical violence by an intimate partner, and forty eight point eight percent have experienced stalking. Sixty four percent of trafficking survivors in Hawaii identified as being part Native Hawaiian. Unfortunately, while these numbers are staggering, it's likely even higher, as according to the Bureau of Indian Affairs, less than half of the violent crimes against Indigenous women are ever reported to the police. This crisis is described as being quote the legacy of generations of government policies of forced removal, land seizures and violence inflicted on Native peoples, a crisis that is very much prevalent and in fact continuously on the rise in this day and age. According to the Dickinson Press, in the first two months of the investigation,
15:32 twenty one thousand dollars was gathered by anonymous contributors to offer as a reward for any information that could lead to a person or persons that may have been responsible for Olby's disappearance or who may have harmed her in some way. That January, another five thousand dollars was offered by the Institute for Trafficked, Missing and Exploited Persons as well as its founder, Patrick Atkinson. This reward was specifically four in the event of foul play any information that led to the arrest and conviction of those involved. Of the reward, Matthew said, quote, ITMP possesses very useful insight and knowledge that will aid in our search efforts. We are thankful to mister Atkinson and ITEMP for the kindness extended to us. We certainly support their work and appreciate them supporting ours. Also in December, the Tribal Business Council of the three affiliated tribes, according to the Bismarck Tribune, authorized the Bureau of Indian Affairs to take over the investigation, and they officially took over in February of twenty eighteen.
16:40 With the BIA taking over, the Lone Bear family was hopeful that real progress would be made in the investigation and more resources would be provided to aid in the search efforts. However, the family was left disappointed once again. Lake Sakakaweya couldn't be properly searched after the first few months of Oliviya's Deday appearance, as it had frozen over, but by April, when it had thought a water search was supposed to be conducted, according to the Bismarck Tribune, though that July, months after the lake was capable of being searched again, nothing had happened due to what was allegedly the various investigative agencies not being able to agree on who was conducting this search. Also adding to investigative issues was a reported constant stream of new agents coming into the BIA, and no one in specific was being assigned to Olivia's case. It appeared as if it had fallen to the wayside. Matthew said, quote, it's kind of hit or miss. We now have a revolving door of agents that come in and some don't know about the case.
17:47 They can't learn seven months worth of a case in two weeks and have that be effective. While Matthew was pushing to have the FBI get involved in Olivia's case after a consistent lack of results, they at least initially seemed unwilling to comment on any potential involvement. Even the law enforcement seemed unwilling to continue conducting searches. Matthew was taking matters into his own hands, reaching out to Karen von Fassen, the minister of Bismarck's Unitarian Universalist Fellowship, for assistance in organizing a larger search party to try and locate the Silverado or Olivia herself. The plan was to have volunteers go through various towns in close proximity to where she had last been known to be. Von Fassen said of the search in Bismarck, quote, what we are doing is literally driving up and down, back and forth on every street and checking every street and alleyway in the areas that we sign up for. Von Fassen said.
18:44 The purpose was to be there for Olivia and her family, and volunteers utilized red ribbons to show local community members that they were there to get results and find her. Volunteers in other towns did the same, and they were also vocal in trying to raise funds for additional searches. In July of twenty eighteen, nine months after Olivia was last seen, Lyssa Yellowbird Chase and the Saunish scouts set out onto Lakes Atakueya themselves in a small boat equipped with sonar, focusing their search on Saanish Bay, in the same place that police had searched when Olivia had been reported missing. They discovered something located four hundred feet from shore and about twenty feet deep in the water. Based on the sonar imaging, they believed what they had found was a vehicle, the approximate shape and size of the pickup truck that they were looking for. Lisa called the three affiliated tribes police as well as the Montreal County Sheriff to report what she had found, and on July thirty first, law enforcement and North Dakota Fish and Game Department divers investigated and discovered exactly where Lyssa and her team had indicated, a blue Chevy Silverada with a dented tailgate in the pass and seed of the car buckled in was the body of a woman, and that body was later identified through various visible tattoos as being Olivia Loanebear.
20:11 While her family was devastated at the discovery and angry at how long it had taken to find her, they did find a small sense of solace in being able to lay her to rest. Olivia's uncle tough First said, in an interview with Teenogue, quote, I'm still confused and angry. It's hard to find the right words. When she first disappeared, her two brothers, her uncle, and myself searched on eTV's every day. We all prayed so hard to find her. Those of us on her mom's side of the family are so heartbroken. We have some closure now that she has been found and laid to rest, but we are still wondering who did this to her. However, while the Lone Bear family and the community wanted answers, the FBI and the BIA were not willing to share information with the public or even with the family. Even over a year after Olba's body had been found, her family had no answers on how she had died or the circumstances surrounding how she had ended up in the lake in the first place. According to an article for The Jamestown Son, while Harley had received Olivia's death certificate identifying her cause of death as undetermined, he had yet to receive a report of death detailing the cause and manner of her death.
21:29 Matthew spoke of how his family was left in the dark, and they had received no updates since she had been found. Though a report of death is public record eight days after it has been completed, When news outlets as well as the family made requests for it, the University of North Dakota's Department of Pathology, who works with the Grand Forks County Coroner's Office, refused to release it, citing the ongoing active investigation. North Dakota Attorney General Wayne Stenigem wrote in his opinion that the report was exempt from state open record laws if considered quote active criminal intelligence and investigative information Media organization. Attorney Jack MacDonald, in response, said he believes quote a report of death is public record regardless of whether it is part of an investigation. My only concern is that it allows law enforcement to take what are ordinarily public records and make them private just because they are using them to investigate. I think it gives them too wide a latitude that's not needed. While an autopsy has never been released, it was ultimately announced that a cause and manner of death could not be determined, but any other information relating to the status of the investigation into what happened to Olivia was not released or commented on with FBI spokesperson Kevin Smith, citing that discussing the case could be detrimental to any future developments. It could also negatively impact getting justice for Olivia and her family.
23:02 The FBI has said that they've issued search warrants and subpoenas in the case, as well as conducting interviews with witnesses, but the statement feels like a cop out and sounds very much like they don't actually have any answers for her family because they haven't said anything even years after the fact. In the interim, Matthew, angry with how the investigation had been conducted since the beginning, began drafting a protocol for missing persons, specifically for tribe members, as well as drafting procedures for law enforcement personnel on how to properly conduct a thorough search. According to the Dickinson Press, his hope was that these protocols would address the problems he and his family had experienced during the search for Olivia and would prevent other families from having to go through it as well. He said, quote, we want to take it to other tribes in the state of North Dakota and unify them so that everything is on the same terms because a lot of time what we were hearing from law enforcement was, well, that's different on other reservations. Additionally, the Office of the North Dakota Indian Affairs Commissioner was also working on a draft for best practices in searching for missing persons in Indian country. Commissioner Scott Davies, who works as a liaison between tribal police and government entities, said he was adamant that they needed to be properly trained on how to work together in future searches. The BIA, in response, announced that they would be increasing staffing efforts on cases occurring on the reservation, and the Department of
24:35 Justice announced that they would be increasing training to improve the quality of investigations in how to work effectively with different agencies. In twenty nineteen, the FBI offered up a ten thousand dollars reward for information relating to Olivia's death and the person or persons responsible, and US Attorney Drew Wrigley released a statement saying, quote, we remain resolute in our commitment to work closely with federal, state, tribal, and local law enforcement as we pursue all emerging evidence in this investigation. And we will continue to pursue all leads and pathways on the road to the truth. That's our pledge to Olivia and to those who knew and loved her. Unfortunately, as of today, Olivia's case remains unsolved and there is very little information or updates available. After twenty nineteen, the FBI has released no additional information, and even though she had been found in the passenger seat of the truck, suggesting that someone else had been driving and had gotten out of the vehicle, her case is not categorized as a homicide, though the possibility of foul play has not been ruled out. One of the many problems in the investigation, besides how it was handled by law enforcement from the beginning, is that there is no definitive cause for why she would have been prevented from getting out of the vehicle when it went into the water. Nothing was found in time psychology testing that would have rendered her unconscious or making her unaware of what was happening, and there was
26:06 no trauma found on her body to suggest that she had been injured or had already been deceased before she went into the water. If anything was found in the forensic processing of the Silverado that was never released, but after spending nine months underwater. It's possible that critical evidence needed to provide answers as to what happened had been destroyed by the investigation getting off to a painfully slow start and issues over jurisdiction, which is common with crimes occurring on reservations. It's likely that vital evidence was missed in the search for her. Olivia's case and its lack of resolution is unfortunately not unusual. Every day the epidemic of missing a murdered Indigenous women gets worse and very few of the cases are solved because of the very same problems her family experienced, and that's not right. If you have any information regarding the death of Bolivia Loane Bearer, please call the FBI at one eight hundred call FBI, or you can submit a tip at FBI dot tips dot gov. As usual, those will both be in the source notes. I'll also include a link to Adventures with Purpose that I mentioned at the start of this episode, so you can see what they do and some of the families they've been able to bring peace to. As always, I thank you so much for listening, and I hope you have a wonderful week, and I will see you in the next chapter of the Book of the Dead. Bye, guys,
27:38 Another page closed. But the story isn't over for the families left behind, the pain doesn't end when the headline's fade. And for the victims, we owe them more than silence for our on solved cases. If you have any information, please reach out to local authorities or visit our show notes for links and resources. Someone out there knows something, maybe it's you. Thank you for listening to the Book of the Dead. If this story moved or spoke to you in some way, talk about it, share it, keep their names alive. Until next time, I'm Courtney Liso. Stay safe, stay curious, and stay vigilant, and remember the dead may be gone, but their stories will not be forgotten.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed