Chapter 83: A Romeo & Juliet Scenario-The Murder of Joanne Witt
Joanne Witt knew better than anyone that parenting wasn't always the easiest job in the world, but when her 14-year-old daughter, Tylar, started hanging around with a much older teen named Steven Colver, things got a lot more difficult. When Joanne...
Joanne Witt knew better than anyone that parenting wasn't always the easiest job in the world, but when her 14-year-old daughter, Tylar, started hanging around with a much older teen named Steven Colver, things got a lot more difficult. When Joanne banned steven from coming around her daughter with the threat of pressing charges, Tylar and Steven came up with a plan to get Joanne off their backs so they could be together forever.
Connect with us on Social Media!
You can find us at:
Instagram: @bookofthedeadpod
X: @bkofthedeadpod
Facebook: The Book of the Dead Podcast
TikTok: Bookofthedeadpod
Or visit our website at www.botdpod.com
ABC News. (2011a, June 4). “Juliet” Teen, Tylar Witt, describes her “Romeo,” Steven Colver, killing mom. https://abcnews.go.com/US/juliet-teen-tylar-witt-describes-romeo-steven-colver/story?id=13757722ABC News. (2011b, September 20). California Teen “Romeo and Juliet” suicide pact goes awry after mom’s murder. https://abcnews.go.com/US/teen-romeo-juliet-suicide-pact-awry-moms-murder/story?id=14511861Acosta, N. (2023, September 9). After mom is found fatally stabbed, teen daughter and boyfriend point fingers at each other. Peoplemag. https://people.com/people-magazine-investigates-star-crossed-killers-joanne-witt-7966560Bliss. (2024, June 16). Forbidden Lovers End Mom to Stay Together - Bliss - Medium. Medium. https://medium.com/@theretrobliss/forbidden-lovers-end-mom-to-stay-together-64e523226888Cost of living in El Dorado Hills, CA | PayScale. (n.d.). https://www.payscale.com/cost-of-living-calculator/California-El-Dorado-Hills#Forbidden young love ends with a mother’s violent murder. (2013, June 9). CBS News. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/forbidden-young-love-ends-with-a-mothers-violent-murder/Gedulin, B. L. O. O. G. (2023, June 15). Age of consent & Statutory rape laws in California. Law Office of George Gedulin. https://www.gedulinlaw.com/blog/2023/june/age-of-consent-statutory-rape-laws-in-california/#:~:text=What%20are%20the%20legal%20consequences,jail%20term%20of%20one%20year.Rasmussen, A. (n.d.). Teenage Couple Murdered Mother Who Accused Daughter’s Older Boyfriend Of Statutory Rape. Investigation Discovery. Retrieved August 31, 2024, from https://www.investigationdiscovery.com/crimefeed/id-shows/people-magazine-investigates/teenage-couple-murdered-mother-who-accused-daughters-older-boyfriend-of-statutory-rapeRatajczak, J. (2011a, June 7). Colver murder trial: Tylar’s stare ‘as if her mom didn’t exist,’ witness testifies. Village Life. https://www.villagelife.com/news/local/colver-murder-trial-tylar-s-stare-as-if-her-mom-didn-t-exist-witness-testifies/article_ca7aea68-1390-518a-8321-c1a2d1c74205.htmlRatajczak, J. (2011b, August 12). Witt, Colver sentenced. Village Life. https://www.villagelife.com/news/local/witt-colver-sentenced/article_76e18da7-c02b-5ab5-95b3-22c74baa6a3d.htmlRatajczak, J. (2011c, August 12). Young murderers’ fate sealed at sentencing. Mtdemocrat. https://www.mtdemocrat.com/news/young-murderers-fate-sealed-at-sentencing/article_94cfa56f-b154-5a02-983a-c14be7a24db2.htmlSaunt, R. (2023, September 17). Chilling case of young girl, 14, and her boyfriend, 19, who brutally slaughtered her mom after she. . . Mail Online....
0:00 Hi guys. I'm Courtney and I'm Lisa, and welcome to the next chapter in the Book of the Dead. Brought to you by dark Cast Network indie podcasts with a twist. Hello, Hello, Welcome to the next chapter in the Book of the Dead. The story I have for you today is about forbidden love and the lengths someone would go to to get what they want. A story where the perpetrators were likened to a twisted version of Romeo and Juliet. As most of you know, having probably read the famous Shakespeare play in school, Romeo and Juliet star cross lovers took their own lives to be together. They were from rival families and their love was forbidden, so they took matters into their own hands. Like Romeo and Juliet, the lovers in this story were prohibited from being together and they took drastic measures to change this. This is the murder of joe Anne Witt. Joe Anne Witt was born in Santa Clara, California, to Norb and Judy Wit on January twenty fifth, nineteen sixty two. She was described as a gourmet chef and a devoted friend. Norbes said quote she never had a
1:32 bad word to say about anybody. She was one of four children in the whit household. She had two brothers and a sister, and when she was in her thirties, she became a single mother, raising a daughter she named Tyler in El Dorado Hills, California now El Dorado Hills is a suburb of Sacramento, California, with a population of over fifty thousand. It reportedly has a low crime rate, which a lot of appeal, and it's also very expensive. According to payscale dot com, the housing expenses are one hundred and forty seven percent higher than the national average, and utilities are twelve percent higher. Transportation fare like buses and gas are twenty two percent higher, and the cost of groceries is eight percent higher. Obviously, to live in an area like this, one needs to have a good job, and Joanne did. She had a master's degree in mechanical engineering and worked as an engineer for El Dorado County.
2:38 According to ABC News, she and the father of her child broke up while Joanne was still pregnant with Tyler, and she raised her by herself. Joanne and Tyler lived in a gated community and Joanne provided Tyler with as many opportunities as she could, like acting classes and writing lessons, and taking Tyler on various traps hips. Tyler told twenty twenty how her mom was a skilled cook and very much a tomboy as well as an accomplished engineer. Tyler said quote, she was a lot like a dad. What other mom catches snakes and lizards and puts them into an aquarium. I don't think I ever appreciated what my mom did for me. When you were a kid, the only thing that you see are parents doing stuff for you and then punishing you. Now, Joanne and Tyler did have a tumultuous relationship, beginning from very early on. When Tyler was in preschool, she had shown up to class with suspicious bruises, and according to what Joanne's sister Mary told ABC, Joanne admitted to getting angry while driving Tyler to school and pulled over, dragging Tyler from the car, smacking her, and hitting Tyler with a belt. This was reported and Tyler was removed from Joanne's care while she was ordered to attend anger management classes. Joane completed the classes and vowed that it would never happen again. It never did, but Tyler and Joanne's relationship continued to suffer
4:09 as Tyler grew into a teenager. Tyler claims this was due to a secret drinking problem that Joanne had, but I couldn't substantiate that. What I can tell you is that reportedly Joanne was trying really hard. But parents and children argue, and many of these arguments stems from Tyler wanting to know who her father was. Joanne wouldn't tell her, and Mary claimed it was because Joanne didn't want him in their lives. However, according to Joanne's friend Rock San Jergeit, Joanne lived in fear of disciplining Tyler too strongly in the event Tyler would call CPS. Tyler apparently took advantage of this fear and would make veiled threats about calling if her mom told her no when she wanted to do something. In December of two thousand eight, Joanne was forty seven and Tyler was fourteen when she started spending time at a local coffee shop. According to medium dot com, at this coffee shop is where Tyler met nineteen year old Stephen Culver. Stephen had just started at the local community college. He dressed in black gothic clothing, and Tyler was completely enamored by him. They started talking almost every day, and before long they had entered into a sexual relationship, something that Tyler hid from Joanne. To her mother, who was concerned about the possibility of Tyler dating Stephen given their age gap, Tyler said they were just good friends.
5:41 He was like a big brother to her. She also told joe Anne that Stephen, who went by the nickname Boston, was gay. Now Joanne seemed to believe her daughter, even though others in their lives had their reservations, but Tyler continued to see him, saying that he was a great listener and he was there for her. Quote. I had had a really bad day. I called him up and said I just needed someone to talk to. He would come by my house and we would just talk. But Stephen was also introducing Tyler to things that were dangerous. According to Joanne's father, Norb he told ABC quote, he had a fourteen year old that looked at him as a god. I mean he had total control over her.
6:28 We knew that drugs were involved. They were into marijuana, ex c cocaine. What does that do to someone's mind? A few months into their relationship. In March or April of two thousand and nine, Joanne was looking for someone to rent a room in her house to help with the mortgage payment, and Tyler suggested that Steven be the one to move in now. According to all sources, everyone in joe Anne's life told her that Stephen moving in was a very bad idea. Norbes said quote no one, every friend she had, everyone in the family did not want him in there. But Joanne was very strong willed, so Stephen moved in. Joe Anne said that he could be there to help Tyler with her homework, and he would be paying five hundred dollars a month in rent to help out with the mortgage. However, Joanne would soon grow suspicious about Tyler and Steven's relationship, noticing that they were far closer than she had anticipated. On May fourteenth, according to Medium, Joanne went looking for Tyler in the house but couldn't find her, so she knocked on Stephen's door.
7:44 After a few minutes, Steven opened the door. He was shirtless and in the closet naked was Tyler, hiding and covering herself with her discarded clothing. Joanne immediately decided that Stephen needed to go, so she called up two of her coworkers to help get Stephen out of the house. Vinnie Capetano told ABC, quote, she said she was going to kick Stephen out and she didn't want to be there alone. So Vinnie and the other coworker came in brought all of Stephen's belongings to the curb. Vinnie said, quote, the first thing I said to him is if it was me, you'd be in jail right now. Joanne did want to call the cops, mind you, but Tyler begged her not to. Joanne told Stephen that she wouldn't if he cut all contact with her daughter, and Vinnie said, in an effort to intimidate Stephen into leaving Tyler alone, quote, you know, if you make contact with Tyler again, either by phone or in person, I'm going to hurt you, and I'm going to hurt you East Coast style, not West Coast style. But Stephen was unfazed by threats of Bottler harm or the police because he and Tyler continued to see each other while Joanne was working or late at night while joe Aanne was asleep. A few days after the discovery, of their relationship. Tyler disappeared to a friend's house, and Joanne, in a panic, called the police
9:17 and told them about what had happened with Stephen. When Tyler was found later that day, police questioned her about having a sexual relationship with Stephen, but she denied it. According to Medium, she admitted being in his room without clothes on, but she claimed she was trying on different outfits to get his opinion when her mom walked in, it was just a misunderstanding. Police pulled Stephen into the station to speak to him as well, but his story was the same as Tyler's. Lacking proof, the police let Tyler go back home and nothing happened regarding an arrest. After this incident with the police, Tyler and Joanne's relationship continued to deteriorate. She was still talking to and seeing Stephen behind Joanne's back, and Joanne was frustrated with her daughter's rebellion. This led to explosive arguments between the two, and Tyler started making claims to CPS that Joanne was beating her, but there was never any evidence to prove that.
10:16 No bruises, no marks, nothing. At some point, the police recalled by Tyler pretending to be Joanne, saying that her daughter had assaulted her, hoping the police would remove her from her mother's custody because in Tyler's mind, being in juvie was better than being with her mom. Now, Joanne did get on the phone trying to explain the situation and told the dispatcher that she didn't know she was safe in her home, as Tyler had started throwing things at her, and that she had in fact attacked joe Anne. She had a cut on her chin and bruises on her arm. So Tyler was placed in a juvenile detention center, but ultimately released when Joanne decided not to press charges.
11:00 Yes the situation would escalate, however, when Joanne found Tyler's diary in June of two thousand and nine. In the diary, Tyler, much to Joanne's horror, had written a detailed account of all of her sexual encounters to Stephen. It was cold, hard proof that Stephen had committed statutory rape. In the diary, Tyler also had written multiple times that she wished death on her mother for trying to keep Stephen away, something that she had also told her friends as well. Joanne brought the diary to the police and showed them the evidence they needed to arrest Stephen. Now to give you an understanding of the age of consent laws and statutory rape in California, because it's different depending on where you live, I'll give you a quick rundown. According to Goodelinlaw dot com, the age of consent in California is eighteen years old, meaning that someone under the age of eighteen is considered a minor and cannot consent to sexual activity. A person engaging in sexual acts with someone under eighteen can be charged with statutory rape. Now. Statutory rape is defined as a criminal offense that occurs when someone engages in sexual activity with someone under the age of eighteen, regardless of whether or not the minor consents. The consequences vary depending on the degree of the charge. If an adult engages
12:30 in sexual activity with a minor and there is less than a three year age gap, they will be charged with the misdemeanor, which carries a maximum sentence of one year in jail. If the miner is over three years younger, the charge can be a misdemeanor or a felony, and the felony conviction carries a jail term of one to three years. If the adult is twenty one or older and the miner is sixteen or younger, the adult will be charged with felony and the jail sentence can vary from one to four years. Now, again, these are statutory charges or consequences for statutory charges, which is different than sexual abuse relating to a child. They're two totally different things, which is why the sentence is not as harsh. Now, some people may hear this and go they should be getting more, and it obviously would depend on the situation.
13:28 But again, these are statutory charges. They're different. In Stephen and Tyler's case, Stephen was potentially looking at a felony charge as Tyler was at minimum four years younger than him, but again it could have been a misdemeanor. It really depended on what the prosecution wanted. Now. According to a witness named Rosanne Perez, who worked at Jonie's Cafe and Grill in Shingle Springs, Tyler and Joanne came in for dinner on June tenth of two thousand and nine. According to Roseanne, she was so shocked by the look on Tyler's face when they walked in that she actually hesitated going up to them. According to an article for Village life dot Com, Roseanne said, quote, It's something I'll never forget.
14:18 It was a blank stare. I've waited on hundreds of thousands of people, but I have never seen a blank stare like that. Roseanne also overheard a conversation between the two where Joanne allegedly told Tyler that she had made a complaint against steep And for statutory rape. Quote she said, I want you to know I have filed statutory rate charges against him. You know he's in real trouble. But according to Roseanne, Tyler had no reaction to this quote. It was as if her mom didn't exist. It's as if nothing existed. Although I will say that Tyler herself claimed that when she learned her mother had turned over her diary to the police, she completely freaked out. She said, according to ABC, quote, I went into a full blown panic attack, hy preventilating, screaming, shaking. Everything was in that diary.
15:14 There was no way he was going to get out of the charges now, as I said. Rosanne claimed, they came in on the tenth, but it is possible that Tyler learned about the charges prior to this day either way, She went to Stephen and they tried to figure out what to do, including a Romeo and Juliette scenario. Now, this scenario meant that they were going to take their own lives in order to be together forever, but Stephen said that that would be a last resort. However, Tyler insisted they were at the last resort, so Tyler came up with a plan for them to run away to San Francisco, drugging her mom so that Joanne would be delayed in calling the police looking for her. Late in the evening on June eleventh, Tyler and Stephens snuck away from Joanne's home and met up with one of Steven's friends named Matt Whitman. At Matt's house, Tyler and stevens eyed their hair black before leaving with Matt to meet up with more friends and buy drugs, after which they went to Steven's father's house, which was empty as it had been put up for sale. While they were there, Stephen and Tyler told Matt that Stephen had killed Joanne.
16:27 He claimed to have stabbed Joanne with a knife before sneaking Tyler out of the house. He even went to his car and produced the bloody knife as proof. According to medium dot com, Steven's father allegedly showed up at the house around this time. Now it's possible that neighbors had called him saying someone was there, knowing that the house was empty, but I couldn't say for sure why he decided to go to the house, or if that was even true. Either way, the three of them flee the home, dropped Matt off at his house, and Tyler and Stephen drove off to San Francisco. It would be three days before anyone would learn about joe Anne's faith.
17:12 On June fifteenth, Norvin, Joanne's parents had been home for just a few days after a two month cross country trip in their RV, when they got a call from joe Anne's boss, who was very worried about her. According to joe Anne's boss, she hadn't been to work on Friday the twelfth, nor did she show up that day a Monday. That was odd enough, because she was a very reliable employee. But what was even stranger was that Joanne had not called to inform her boss she wouldn't be coming in Norvin. Judy told her boss that they only lived two miles away, so they were going to drive right over to see if she was all right, but Joanne's boss said that he had already called the police to do a welfare check. He told Norb and Judy that Joanne had confided in her co workers that she was having problems with Tyler, and they were very concerned.
18:08 Norb told forty eight hours quote, I got in the car and got over there so fast. I think I was in a daze. By the time I got there, there was two sheriff cars and two deputies out there walking around the house. Norb told police he could unlock the door for them, and he and Judy were told to wait outside while police had a look around. Soon enough, they came back and told them that Joanne was in her upstairs bedroom and she was dead. Norb said, quote, they never said killed or murdered, they just said deceased. So we didn't know what was going on. But when the CSI van came in and we had probably twenty detectives working the place, we knew that she had been killed.
18:53 During their investigation of the scene, Joanne's bedroom was in disarray. The sheets were thrown back, and she was laying on top of the bed with her hands up in a defensive position. She had been covered with a sheet, and she had sustained twenty stab wounds, one of which almost decapitated her. It was determined that Joanne had most likely been killed with a ten inch chef's knife, the location of which they didn't know. All police knew was that it wasn't in the house. The next thing noorbn Judy were concerned with, though, was the whereabouts of their fourteen year old granddaughter. She was nowhere to be found, and they worried she had been kidnapped. However, pretty quickly police set their sights on Tyler, not as a victim, but as a suspect, as investigators learned about the ongoing investigation into Stephen Culver for statutory rape charges submitted by Joanne.
19:50 So now police are trying to figure out where they are. They put out a bolo and are letting police know in other counties to keep an eye out for Steven and Tyler, who are persons of interest Joanne's murder. Meanwhile, in San Francisco, Steven and Tyler have checked into a holiday inn and sent Matt Whitman their suicide letters. They attempted to end their lives by eating cake and candy lease with rat poison, but they stopped before they could eat enough to cause their deaths. They tried other methods to end their lives, and even contemplated jumping from the roof, but Tyler was too afraid of heights to go through with it. According to medium dot com, they soon ran out of ideas and instead got on a train to San Bruno. While there, they were spotted by police changing their clothes behind a mall and promptly arrested. Upon their arrest, Tyler insisted her mother was fine, and they both insisted they were innocent, but police had spoken to Matt Whitman, who gave police the suicide notes and told police about Stephen, admitting to him that he had been the one to kill joe Anne. Before long, Stephen and Tyler had turned on each other, saying that the other was responsible. According to Stephen, when he arrived to Joanne's home to get Tyler, Joanne was already dead and that he lied about being the one to kill her to protect his girlfriend. According to Jan Culver, Steven's mother, lying to protect someone he
21:20 cared about was something he would do she said quote he would care about others before himself, to his detriment, Stephen is the kind of guy who would dive off a cliff, or jump in front of a bullet, or run into a burning home for a friend. Stephen claimed that Tyler had come to the door covered in blood, holding the knife she used to kill Joanne, but police never found any evidence of blood anywhere except in Joanne's bedroom. Additionally, police had found DNA evidence under Joanne's nails. While there wasn't enough to build a full profile to match to anybody, experts were able to conclude that the DNA came from a male. Now, Tyler was obviously telling a different story.
22:05 According to her, Stephen had shown up at her house with his own knife, although police believed they took one from the kitchen before creeping up the stairs to Joanne's bedroom. When it was time to go in, Tyler refused and fell to the ground covering her ears as Stephen killed her mother. In the two years before the trial began, Tyler also allegedly took a polygraph, which she passed, but she was unable to remember which one of them came up with the idea to kill her mother. She was also not considered a credible witness, as she had lied various times to police before the murder about her relationship with Stephen. A psychiatrist even claimed she was sociopathic. However, as the trial drew closer, Tyler, now sixteen, struck a deal with prosecution. She would testify again on Stephen, cooperate with police and tell them where they had hid in the knife in exchange for a lesser sentence of second degree murder. Now, police, even with Tyler's help, never found the murder weapon. She claimed she threw it down a storm drain, and it is believed the storms washed it away.
23:18 During the trial, when asked why she had taken the plea deal, Tyler claimed she had found God and was compelled by him to tell the truth. During her testimony, she claimed they had both come up with the plant to stab Joanne and that they could use a knife from the home, but Stephen said he would provide one, but when it came time to actually committing the murder quote, I couldn't do it. I couldn't go inside. I put my hands over my ears, closed my eyes and hummed. She also admitted to lying about her relationship with Stephen and revealed that she had frequently told her friends she wished her mother would die. And cross examination, Tyler also told the court how she had a demon living inside of her named Toby and an angel named Alex. Quote three souls in one body. Toby's very cold. She holds everyone in contempt. Tyler described how she would have done anything for Stephen quote I trusted him more than anyone, and I loved him more than anybody or anything. If he told me to jump off a bridge and I asked him why and he said, just trust me, I would have done it. Ultimately. In June of twenty eleven, Stephen Culver was sentenced to life in prison for the murder of joe Annwitt. In response, Deputy District Attorney Lisette Suitors said, quote, mister Culver took the life of a person who took him in, adding that his apparent lack
24:51 of remorse was enraging, and Judge Daniel Proud said, quote no person deserves to die in the manner that took place for Tyler. She was sentenced to fifteen years in prison for second degree murder due to the plea agreement she took. Judge Prowd told her quote, this was a brutal murder. The court has seen no emotion or even remorse for the loss of your mother. I'm sorry for you, miswit, because the person who loved you most in this world and without reservation, is gone. Tyler was not eligible for parole until last month, but she was apparently released in twenty twenty two at the age of twenty eight. The only information I could find of her now is that she seems to be going by the name Charlie. As for Stephen, while his mother had said after sentencing they would appeal, it looks like it never happened, because there hasn't been any updates on him since the trial concluded.
25:55 This was a murder that didn't have to end the way it did. Tyler and Stephen were so afraid that he would end up in jail for the rest of his life for statutory rape, but according to ly said suitor, he most likely would have been charged with a misdemeanor and served a year at the most. Now Stephen is serving life in prison for murder instead of the two of them just owning up to having an inappropriate relationship. Joanne's murder was senseless and it's clear that she was simply trying to encourage her daughter to make smarter decisions about who she was entertaining a relationship with. But Tyler couldn't take no for an answer, and it seems as if Tyler's family, at least at the time of the trial, had completely dropped her, completely disowned her. In fact, Norbe had refused to see her until the trial had even started, so for two years because he couldn't look at her for what she had done to her mother. He did say in an interview with ABC that he had entertained the idea of forgiving Tyler, but he's not there yet and it's hard for him to separate the idea of the granddaughter he knew and loved with the girl that had done this. And as for jan Steven's mother, she still insists he's innocent. And then Tyler was the one to kill joe Anne, but I think he was rightfully so the one that did it. And what put the
27:27 nail in the coffin for him was admitting to Matt Whitman that he had killed Joanne. The DNA under her fingernails definitely didn't help his case. There was no female DNA under there to indicate Tyler only male. This was definitely a sad case, and it's a case where it should have turned out so differently if they had just been honest with what was going on, but they didn't want to get in trouble and they made it so much much worse. I appreciate you guys for listening as always and keep an ear on for an episode that's going to drop with Yield Crime. I'm going to be on there. I have no idea where the when the episode is going to release on their platform, but yeah, I'm going to go hang out with Lindsay and do a little segment for them, and I'm very excited. It's going to be a lot of fun. In the meantime, I thank you for your patience. I know this episode is up later than it was supposed to be, but technology and me don't always get along, but it worked out in the end. So as always, have a wonderful week and I will see you in the next chapter of the Book of the Dead. Bye, guys, thank you so much for listening to this chapter of the Book of the Dead, and don't forget that you can always connect with us on Instagram. You can connect with us
28:58 on Twitter and you can absolutely connects with us on Patreon. We also have a merch store as well that we have frequent discount codes coming out for so that you guys can get March hand drawn by myself at a better cost. We hope you have a lovely rest of your week and just remember please be kind and don't forget to always stay safe, stay curious, and stay vigilant. Bye guys, Bye,
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed