Welcome to The Book of the Dead
The Book of the Dead
The Book of the Dead
A weekly true crime podcast, hosted by Courtney Liso, where every chapter we turn the page to dive into a crime and victim's story that we refuse to let be forgotten. From unsolved crimes, missing persons cases, and interviews with experts in the field, every chapter aims to give a voice back to those who had it taken from them.
Oct. 30, 2024

Chapter 86: Execution of an Innocent Man-The Murders of Narnie Bryson and Sister Tadea Benz

Chapter 86: Execution of an Innocent Man-The Murders of Narnie Bryson and Sister Tadea Benz
Chapter 86: Execution of an Innocent Man-The Murders of Narnie Bryson and Sister Tadea Benz
The Book of the Dead
Chapter 86: Execution of an Innocent Man-The Murders of Narnie Bryson and Sister Tadea Benz

"I’d like to thank my family for loving me and taking care of me. And the rest of the world can kiss my ass.”

After the murder nun in Amarillo, Texas, police are convinced they found their killer. Johnny Frank Garrett was tried, sentenced, and...

"I’d like to thank my family for loving me and taking care of me. And the rest of the world can kiss my ass.”

After the murder nun in Amarillo, Texas, police are convinced they found their killer. Johnny Frank Garrett was tried, sentenced, and executed for the murder of Sister Tadea Benz, but this case is not as straightforward as it seems. From the misconduct of a medical examiner, calls for clemency from Pope John Paul II, omitted evidence, and a second murder that police knew was tied to Sister Tadea's, this is a case where nothing is as it seems. The murders of two women were a rabbit hole that concluded with the realization that Johnny Frank Garrett was executed for a crime he probably didn't commit. This is the story that inspired a movie and three people who were victims of a killer and the justice system.

Connect with us on Social Media!
You can find us at:
Instagram: @bookofthedeadpod
X: @bkofthedeadpod
Facebook: The Book of the Dead Podcast
TikTok: Bookofthedeadpod
Or visit our website at www.botdpod.com


Actual Innocence: Johnny Frank Garrett and Bubbles The Clairvoyant. (n.d.). http://www.skepticaljuror.com/2010/04/fine-folks-of-amarillo-wanted-justice.htmlAmarillo youth, 17, arrested in rape-slaying of Catholic nun. (n.d.). Amarillo Daily News, 1a–3a. http://www.thelastworddocumentary.com/upfiles/l59.pdfAmnesty International. (n.d.). EXTERNAL (for general distribution) AI Index: AMR 51/04/92 [Report]. https://www.amnesty.org/en/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/amr510041992en.pdfAssociated Press. (1992, February 12). TEXAS EXECUTES KILLER OF A NUN. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/1992/02/12/us/texas-executes-killer-of-a-nun.htmlBates, C. (1981, November 5). Slaying evidence goes to D.C. Amarillo Daily News. http://www.bloodshedbooks.com/upfiles/l64.pdfBrown, C. (2019, March 7). Pathologist Accused of Falsifying Autopsies, Botching Trial Evidence : Forensics: His recent indictment on charges of falsifying reports and having sloppy habits has attorneys scrambling to pinpoint any wrongful convictions. - Los Angeles Times. Los Angeles Times. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1992-04-12-mn-286-story.htmlCarrillo, K. J., & Carrillo, K. J. (2023, August 9). The Mariel Boatlift: How Cold War politics drove thousands of Cubans to Florida in 1980. HISTORY. https://www.history.com/news/mariel-boatlift-castro-carter-cold-warComplaint No. 26861-C. (2004). In bloodshedbooks.com (APD 1981-00015340). Amarillo Police Department. http://www.bloodshedbooks.com/upfiles/l30.pdfCooper, L. (2014, August 2). Clear the name of a man who was killed on death row for a crime he didn’t commit.Change.org. https://www.change.org/p/rep-louie-gohmert-clear-the-name-of-a-man-who-was-killed-on-death-row-for-a-crime-he-didn-t-commitFuqua, L. M. (2021, December 12). A convent nun murdered on Halloween — True crime - true crime addiction - medium. Medium. https://medium.com/true-crime-addiction/a-convent-nun-murdered-on-halloween-true-crime-938b61d3afbfGarrett’s Death Row Letters. (n.d.). http://www.bloodshedbooks.com/tour.php?category=Garrett%27s+Death+Row+Letters#Goldfarb, K. (2018, April 26). Was Johnny Frank Garrett a sadistic Nun-Killer or an innocent man put to death?All That’s Interesting. https://allthatsinteresting.com/johnny-frank-garrettJEAN PAGEL ASSOCIATED PRESS. (n.d.)....

0:00 Hi guys. I'm Courtney and I'm Lisa, and welcome to the next chapter in the Book of the Dead, brought to you by Dark Cast Network indie Podcasts with a Twist. Hello, Hello, Welcome to the Halloween episode of the Book of the Dead. I have a surprise for you. Guess who's back. I think she's referring to me, Although that's probably not a good surprise for some of you.

0:43 I'm going to get it out of the way now because I already know people are going to ask, because people have asked, how are you feeling. I am feeling better. I did have a little bit of some medical issues I had to deal with, still dealing with one, but I am totally fine, will be fine. Just I guess irritated that I have to do this. That makes sense, makes sense? Yeah, like I said, people were asking, I was very vague. Don't worry. I said, you got into a car accident, that you were okay. It wasn't like a serious car accident, but you were dealing with things because of set car accident. Yes, we're going to jump right in now. Just everybody, remember that I know nothing of this story at all, nothing, So my commentary or response, however you want to term it is a completely raw reaction. So I don't want, you know, anybody to think that I'm, I don't know, making up my response or have you.

1:47 It's not scripted. It's what she's trying to say. Little refresh, heir. There you go, it's not scripted. Well, her responses aren't scripted obviously, like I have notes that I follow, But either way, we're gonna jump right in. So it's rare for me to cover a case where I have my doubts about the person convicted of the crime that was committed. In fact, the last time I covered a case where I had these reservations was when we covered the murder of the McStay family and I expressed some doubt that Chase Merritt was responsible for the family's murdyrs. You remember that, Yes, I do. So it's been a long time. That was two years ago. Now it's been that long. It has it's been two years since we covered that case. Now, the case I'm going to tell you about is similar in that someone who is potentially innocent was convicted. But the difference between the two cases is that there is someone out there who was convicted of a very similar crime that may have been responsible. In fact, this man allegedly claimed he was responsible and honestly in full transparency.

2:50 The more I researched what happened, the more I'm inclined to believe that an innocent man was convicted for a crime he didn't commit. And this case didn't start out like that. At face value, it seems very cut dry. Someone was brutally murdered, a killer was found, the evidence seemed to support it, They go to trial, they're convicted. But digging deeper led me to an entirely different side of the story, one involving another murder and alleged cover up, the misconduct of a medical examiner, and the involvement of the pope. So these are the murders of Narnie Bryson and sister Tada Bents. Okay, I'm when you say sister you.

3:33 Mean Anon yet. Okay. Now, before we can dive into the murders, we have to do a brief history lesson and talk about the Mariial boatlift of nineteen eighty. I don't know if you know anything. About that a little bit, not too much, okay, or not that I remember too much? Okay. So to give you a general overview. After the US trade embargo of nineteen sixty two, as well as various powers alone ligning themselves with the US, which pulled support from Cuba. During Fidel Castro's reign or presidency, I should say, Cuba's economy was crippled and many Cubans were vocal about seeking asylum. These asylum efforts started in nineteen seventy two and went on until nineteen eighty when Fidel Castro, furious with the descent of the Cuban people, surprisingly opened the border of the Port of Mariel, which was the closest port to the US, and said basically that anyone who wanted to leave, get out, and he did this on May first of nineteen eighty. They had six months now.

4:37 He had said, according to history dot com quote, those who have no revolutionary genes, those who have no revolutionary blood, we do not want them, We do not need them. So one hundred and twenty five thousand people unchanged fled Cuba, and President Jimmy Carter said that they would be welcomed with open arms. He established the Cuban Haitian and tra program in June of nineteen eighty which granted temporary status and access to asylum, processing and community assistance to both Cubans and thousands of Haitians fleeing to the United States. So Fidel Castro took advantage of this and deported convicted criminals, mental hospital patients, sex workers, and members of the LGBTQ, and anyone else that Fidel Castro deemed to be less than He essentially said, Jimmy Carter, you wanted them so bad, you can have them. So of the one hundred and twenty five thousand plus people to arrive in Florida, over twenty thousand had a criminal record. Now, obviously, the Cuban and Haitian people that arrived in droves seeking political asylum weren't exactly welcomed with the open arms that Jimmy Carter claimed they would be, And that's something that would take an entire episode to delve into, but it was essentially because he said thirty five hundred people can be granted asylum, Fidel Castro won't know you could have every so they were vastly underprepared for the sheer volume of people that arrived in Florida. The reason I mentioned the boat lift

6:09 is because as I said, it wasn't just people seeking asylum that came to the US, cast criminals as well, and some of them were incredibly violent, which will be relevant later. So in nineteen eighty one, in Amarillo, Texas, someone was prying on elderly women for months, from at least May until October. There were various attacks on women with ages ranging from mid to late seventies all the way into their nineties. While many of these women thankfully survived, at least two were killed after being brutally beaten and violently sexually assaulted. One was left in a coma for a brief time. And it's obvious to anyone that these are horrific crimps. It's obvious, but it seems as if the attacks were spread far enough apart that police didn't see connection, and the citizens of Amarillo weren't fearful of a violent person on the loose habitually committing these atrocities.

7:09 Was it out in the papers and whatnot? It was, but it wasn't like they weren't so close together, Like one woman was attacked save this week, and then a few weeks later someone else was attacked. Like looking back on it now, it seems very obvious that someone was praying on these women, but at the time I don't think they realized that it was all connected. It was kind of a this is a terrible coincidence that all of these women are being attacked, but we don't think there's like a maniac on the loose. Okay it if it was spaced out, maybe they didn't make the connection. So. On July ninth of nineteen eighty one, the body of seventy seven year old Narnie Bryson was found in the home where she lived alone at seven thirty two North Houston Hill in Amarillo Now. According to an affidavit signed by officer Kenny Dockery, Narnie was found nude in her bedroom. The autopsy findings included numerous broken bones, evidence of genital trauma, and markings indicative of strangulation. The cause of death was determined to be asphyxiation due to strangulation, and the murder weapon was determined to be the core to her telephone.

8:20 This is you know, somebody's loved one. This is their mom, their wife, their grandmother. Unbelievable. Police recovered a hand and fingerprints at the scene, as well as some black curly hair, and they took her bed sheets for evidence. Based on the hair found, they believe that the murderer was a Cuban refugee. And yes, saying this based on some hair found at the scene definitely feels racially charged. But unfortunately, I have very little other information on Narnie's murder. The only thing I can really say in reference to it was that, according to an article for the Amarillo Daily News, Narnie was a member of the Buchanan Street United Methodist Church and she was active in her community doing volunteer work. But it seems as if police didn't have a suspect for a long time. The most notable thing that happened immediately following her murder, which will be relevant, was the arrest of a Cuban man caught peeping in the same neighborhood. But after months of no progress in Narnie Bryson's murder, there is another body found. On Halloween of nineteen eighty one, morning mass was conducted at six thirty am at the Saint Francis Convent at forty three oh one Northeast eighteenth Street, in the same neighborhood that Narnie lived. The nuns convened for service, but someone was missing, and that someone was seventy six year old Sister Tadia. Ben's a very devout nun who never missed a service of Sister Tada. Bishop Lt. Matheasen,

9:53 head of the Amarilla Diocese, said to Donna Weeks from the Amarilla Daily News quote, she gave a wonderful witness to her belief in God. Her whole life was a witness to her belief in God, and she believed in Him and of a future life. A nun went to Sister Tedia's room on the second floor of the convent after Mass at around seven thirty am, where she found Tadiya deceased. Now, while there was some blood present on her face, the nuns assumed that she had passed of natural causes or maybe she had a heart attack, so they phoned a doctor and they were told to call a funeral home to have the body picked up and prepared for burial. Two hours later, police were called when a broken window was found on the north side of the convent. Now, when police arrived and began investigating the break in, they were told about Sister Todya's death. Of course, police were alarmed and, according to the Ameral Daily News, called the Potter County Justice of the Peace LB. Bartlett.

10:52 He in turn called the funeral parlor and put a stop to the embalmit. Now, while Sister Todia's body had been partially cleaned and are material, embombing had already been completed and autopsy was able to be performed. It was performed by doctor Ralph Etterman, and in his report he said that Sister Tadea had been brutally attacked before her death. She had been beaten and raped with semen and foreign fluid recovered from her body. She had also been strangled manually based on the bruising to her neck, and there was stab wounds present on her body. Her time of death was determined to be around four thirty on the morning of October thirty first. Sister Tadia's murder was eerily similar to Narnie Bryson's and police knew they needed to find who was responsible. This race to find the killer was made even more urgent when police learned that another woman had been attacked only hours after Sister Todya's murder.

11:49 A seventy seven year old woman was beaten on conscious in her home and left for dead before a friend found her. Now, luckily, this woman survived and came out of her brief coma, but she was so traumatized she couldn't give any information to police. Police strongly believe that these cases were all linked. According to an article for the Amarilla Daily News, professor Willie Brown from the Criminal Justice Department at Texas State University agreed with the idea that the same person had committed these crimes. He said, quote, there is a good chance that the person attacking older women in Amarillo has done so before, has been arrested for it, and has spent time in prison or a mental hospital for his crime. This person is probably Catholic or raised Catholic, And there is a good chance the nun that was killed was not selected as a particular The decision was made to rape and kill a nun, not any particular nun, just a nun. I am almost sure that this person has lots of religious conflicts, and I have problems believing this person is a longtime resident of Amarilla. So, based on what this professor is saying, he does not believe that the person that did this is a native of Amarillo. He also believes that they have some issues with religion and they've clearly done this before.

13:07 Well. I think if they were able to get in and out of the convent with nobody hearing them, more than likely this person has done it before. At the convent, police gathered whatever evidence they could. In front of the broken window, they found a piece of wood believed to have been used to smash the glass, and in sister Tada's bedroom they managed to get a fingerprint off of her headboard. The sheets on her bed were collected, Some black curly hair was found, and police found two knives. One was a kitchen knife some say it was a butter knife specifically, which was found under her bed, and the other was a steak knife that they found in the driveway of the convent. While police searched the convent for evidence, they also spoke to anyone in the area they could in the hopes they could find a witness.

13:51 Residents near the convent reported seeing a dark skinned Cuban man with dark curly hair near the convent on the morning of the murder, and some witnesses placed the same man at the convent the night before. Incidentally, there was a man in custody suspected of assault and attempted rape of a twenty one year old woman on the day of Sister Toda's murder who matched the description, and this man was twenty eight year old Fernando Flores, who was a Cuban refugee. Okay, so tell me about Fernando. Well, I don't know a lot about Fernando. These witnesses were shown photographs of various men, including Fernando, and they all indicated that he was the man they saw hanging around the convent. Now on November fifth, according to the Amarilla Daily News, Sergeant Greg Sultis, an identification technician for the Major Crime Unit, flew to Washington, DC to deliver evidence from both Narni's and Sister Todaz murders to the FBI to have them analyzed. The evidence included the fibers found on Fernando Flores's clothes, the Harris found at both scenes, both sets of bedsheets, fingerprints found at both crime scenes and the butter night. The Potter County Identification Division Lab also had tests and conducted with the new laser to try and recover additional fingerprints for the knives, but they were hesitant to use it on other evidence, as the laser was used in conjunction with a chemical that they worried would damage the other evidence. After being analyzed by the FBI, the fibers and harris present on Fernando's clothing

15:23 was found to be inconclusive, so police let Fernando go. By the end of the first speak of the investigation, police it seemed had no suspects, but then a clairvoyant came forward and changed everything. This clairvoyant, who went by the name Bubbles and I refused to call her that, claimed to various newspapers that she had a vision and knew who the killer was. According to a blog post by the Skeptical Juror, the clairvoyant claimed that the suspect was a teenager with an olive complexion, a big nose and ears, was half black and white, worn Afro style wig during the murder, and was associated with the name Clyde.

16:05 She also claimed this person lived on the same street as the convent in a small white house. Allegedly, this clairvoyan decided to look for the house herself and came upon a house across the street from the convent with a doghouse out front. This dog house had the name Clyde on it. A couple of days later, a resident of the home named Johnny Frank Garrett was arrested for sister Tedia's murder. He was seventeen years old, slender, with light brown hair, and had a large nose in big ears. His fingerprints were tested and they matched the prince found on the butter knife, as well as the handprint on sister Todiya's headboard. The knife found in the driveway allegedly matched the brand of knives in Johnny's kitchen, although neither of the knives were the ones used to stab sister Tadya.

16:53 Of the arrest, which was made ten days after Sister Todia's murder, District Attorney Danny Hill said, quote, the whole investigation was a concerted effort at the Sheriff's office and police department. I would describe it as a pure stroke of good investigation. Had another twelve to fifteen hours gone by, the body may have been in the ground and nobody would have ever known there was a murder. Now, Johnny was obviously questioned about what happened on the night of sister Toda's murder, However, he was questioned without an attorney or a parent present. According to the Amarillo Police, Johnny allegedly confessed to strangling an assaulting sister to Dia after she woke up in the process of him breaking into her room to look for things to steal, but when it came time to sign the confession, Johnny refused. What's interesting about the confession was that Johnny made no mention of stabbing sister to doa It's also interesting that while two fingerprints matched, the pubic hair found at the scene was confirmed to belong to a Hispanic male with dark hair, while Johnny was Caucasian with lfe brown hair.

18:01 So I'm thinking that they probably have the wrong man or I mean, I don't understand why they would question the teenager without some representation. I agree, and will kind of go into why I think they did. There's also no mention of police finding an Afro style wig in his home, contrary to what the Clairboyan said, and when asked about the black and white comment, because Johnny was fully Caucasian, she said that she saw him painting his face half black and half white, which seems like a weird thing to do. I agree with you on that one.

18:41 But again her statement wasn't rooted. In fact, it was rooted in this belief in a vision that she had. Now up Untiljohnny's arrest, as I said, police were convinced that whoever killed sister Toda had also killed Narnie Bryson, But Johnny was napper asked about this first murder at all, which if police have two murders with very similar mos, I would think that they would have asked Johnny about this murder too. I would think so. But again I am not a police officer, so I don't know how they fully conduct there I'll say interrogation or interview. Johnny is charged with murder and is jailed to await trial.

19:23 While there, he is interviewed by multiple psychologists, and all of them determined that Johnny suffered from brain damage, was mentally impaired, and was chronically psychotic. All is a result of his childhood. Now, Johnny suffered severe sexual abuse as a child at the hands of his stepfather and was trafficked to other men. He was forced to perform sex ax for pornographic pictures and videos, and was physically abused as well. He was introduced to alcohol and drugs at the age of ten, and was also taught to use paint thinner and amphetamines to get high. So this destroyed his brain. The abuse, the drug addiction, all of it, all of it. This man was horrifically abused for most, if not all, of his childhood and it caused severe mental damage and led to paranoid delusions. That right then and there is indicative to me that he's most likely considered criminally insane.

20:20 And what are the crimes do you commit? Just the murder supposedly supposedly, yeah, just the murder, So then I don't think it would be criminally insane. Well, in terms of the trial, that would lead me to believe that he is not. He doesn't have the mental faculties to stand trial. I agree with you. Yes. Prior to his trial, he wrote and received a lot of letters, one of the letters being from his lawyer VG Colius telling him not to testify on his own behalf, and I'll read a portion of it for you. It said, quote, as we explain to you, if you take the stand to testify, you might be impeached. That is the state. We'll try to make a liar out of you by anything that you have said before trial that is different from what you say at the time of the trial.

21:06 Several police officers are going to testify that you told them about entering the convent, going into the nuns room, and choking her and having sex with her. They are going to testify that after you told them all about the crime, that they typed up a statement of what you had said to them, but that you refuse to sign it. As we have explained to you, this statement is not admissible unless you want to get on the witness stand and testify on your own behalf. Also, when your prior statement gets into evidence, there is a strong likelihood that we will not be entitled to our circumstantial evidence charge. As you know, this charge is very favorable to you, and losing it is the loss of a big item in our defense. The reason I am writing you this letter is to make sure that you understand the risk you are taking it take the stand to testify.

21:57 We want you to realize and understand that you you do not have to testify, and whether you testify or not is a decision that you and you alone must make. This is not a decision that we can make for you. Now His lawyer goes on to say that he understands that Johnny wants to get his side of the story out there, but he will not be able to protect Johnny during cross examination. He also told Johnny that if there was anything he didn't understand in the letter, to not sign it, because if he signed it, Coldius said he would take that as Johnny's saying that he would be taking the stand since Johnny would go on to testify at his trial. I can only assume he signed the letter.

22:39 But my question is what did he understand the entire letter? That's what I want to know. I don't know if he fully understood that letter. And it's very clear that the lawyer is trying to help him, like, look, if you don't understand anything in this letter, don't sign it. But why didn't he have that conversation in person. It seems that they did have a conversation in person. What I'm assuming is a lawyer needed something in writing that Johnny was going to testify for legality's sake, so he wrote them this letter after the conversation, laying out the conversation saying, Okay, now if you sign this, you're saying that you're going to testify, but if you don't understand what I'm saying to you in Layman's terms in this letter, do not sign it. You will not testify.

23:27 And I think what it was was that Johnny wanted to testify really bad like he wanted to because he wrote in a letter, in multiple letters, that he didn't get his he didn't get a chance to say his side of the story. Okay, I understand where he's coming from. The trials started in nineteen eighty two, and it went very badly for Johnny. He was allegedly seen running from the convent on the night of the murder, which is interesting because when the police canvassed the area, I can find nothing stating that they had found anyone that plays Tim or anyone matching his description at the convent. They had the prints on the knives, and they said that the pubic hair matched characteristics of Johnny's, which again is interesting because they had no actual DNA evidence to support that, and this was in nineteen eighty nineteen eighty two. I don't believe that DNA evidence was that advanced at that time. True, But we're going to go into what happened with the DNA. Okay, Now, as I mentioned, doctor Erdman recovered fluid and semen from the autopsy, but he didn't have it tested. According to court records, the evidence was discarded by Erdmin because he didn't have the equipment necessary to analyze it.

24:44 Why would you discard it? Wouldn't you send it to a facility that had the equipment necessary to test well? According to doctor Erdman, and we're going to talk all about doctor Erdman, he allegedly said that he got rid of the evidence because he was never told to keep it. Aren't you supposed to keep evidence throughout the trial because if the defense or the prosecution needs it for whatever reason. Yes, no, exactly, you're right. He threw it out. Well, no one told me to keep it. He threw it out. We're going to talk all about doctor Edmund, all about him.

25:25 So they don't have that d in evidence, but there are similar characteristics. An inmate of the Potter County Jail names Lonnie Watley, also testified that Johnny had allegedly denied committing the murders to him before ultimately confessing. And I'm very curious as to what Lonnie got out of testifying because he was an inmate, So like, what did you get in exchange for a testimony. I'm not saying he's lying. I'm just saying, like, what's a valid question. You know, a lot of times inmate testimony is very much a eye scratcher, back, he scratch mine kind of thing. So I'm just saying, when Johnny gets on the stand to testify, he proclaims his innocence. According to court records, Johnny said that he had broken into the convent but two days prior to the murder, looking for things to steal, coming in through the front door. He said he went into the medication room and the cafeteria, and he went into several bedrooms, prying open a locked door with a knife he got from the kitchen. He also said that he had gone into sister to do his room and had braced himself against the headboard, reaching up for a cross on the wall. He said he was startled by a noise and fled, going to his mother's house on the evening off October thirtieth and staying there until the next morning.

26:46 And he claimed that he leapt the exact same way he came in the front door. He never went to a window. Now During the cross examination, Johnny was presented with the unsigned statement he made to police, where he allegedly said he broke his the convent via the broken window and heading into sister to do this room. According to court records, his statement said quote, there was a nun in bed and she acted as if she was going to scream. I covered her mouth so she wouldn't make any noise. I started choking her until she passed out. I had sex with her. I left the convent the way I came in. Now, according to Johnny, he denied this statement ever happened. Quote the police officer would say something and I would say put it down. He would say something else and I would say, go ahead, put it down. Then he said sign this, and I said I ain't signing nothing. So, first of all, it seems to me, at least that the interview wasn't recorded at the time the statement was allegedly made, which is made evident by the fact that they didn't play a recording or anything like that in or during the trial. It seems also that, at least according to Johnny, the police officer who interviewed him was possible leading him in the interview just based on what Johnny was saying, like, you know, the police officer would say this, and Johnny would say, okay, like are you going to write that down? And the police officer wasn't like, kind of I guess, kind of leading him into saying that he killed Sister Tada. Just

28:18 based on the court records and how his testimony went, that sounds very much like what he's kind of implying happened based on the well, you know, I said write it down, like are you going to put that down? And the officer just ignoring that, and then it was okay, sign the statement, and Johnny's going, I'm not signing it now. Also brought to his testify with Sister Bernice Knogler, who claimed that the convent doors were typically kept locked and that Johnny would not have been able to make it inside, let alone all the way to the cafeteria by lunchtime without anyone seeing him. She also claimed that no drawers or chests were kept locked in any of the rooms, and that Sister Tada didn't have a cross hanging over her bed. I am not saying this. None is lying.

29:00 In fact, it's pretty much a given that nuns usually do not lie. I'm also saying, though, that I don't think it is physically impossible for Johnny have made it into the convent without being seen. It's not impossible. No, there's always possibilities. It's also I also don't think that you could say, without a shadow of a doubt unless they personally checked every day the chest and drawers in every room with the convent, that none of them are locked, unless they didn't have a way to be locked, which I don't know. Okay. I also think it's unusual to say that Sister Toia didn't have a cross in her room. Now I don't know she meant that she didn't specifically have a cross hanging over her bed, which again a little unusual, because most very religious people do have a cross hanging over their bed or in their room itsel or, but at the very least that's usually in their room. So again I'm not saying she's lying. I don't know the layout of the room. There's no pictures of what the room looked like like, I have no idea. But at least according to her, what Johnny's saying is not true. It's not possible. I'm saying that there's room for doubt.

30:12 Well, there's always room for doubt, because even if she didn't have a across her crucifix hanging over her bed, it didn't mean that, you know, because old nuns have rosaries that she didn't have that. You know, maybe there was a nail on the wall over her bed and she would hang that before she went to bed, or she had it on her like her bed post. Exactly. Yeah. And you know, Johnny says that he left in Sister Bernice said that nothing was stolen, but that doesn't mean he wasn't trying to steal something, you know, it doesn't mean that he went in there with the intention of killing somebody. He could have very easily have gone in there trying to steal something. But you know, he's seventeen years old. Seventeen year old are kind of anyway.

31:01 They think, ooh, it's a convent, like, you know, there's probably something good to steal in there. And you know, a lot of people, I think don't realize that most nuns live a very like pious simple life. They don't have anything extra extravagant. They're going to have the basic necessities. They're going to have their clothing, they're going to have their bible, maybe a couple of books. It's very simple jewelry. A lot of them were wooden jewelry. It's very possible he went in there looking to steal something and there's nothing really worth stealing, or anything worth stealing was locked away somewhere. Well, I'm sure like if you know, maybe a chalice or you know that are used that's used for certain occasions, or it could be a tray, a silver tray.

31:48 Yeah, or like you know, a like a candle holders you know, maybe you know. So I'm sure there were probably some things too, steel, but probably not where he was looking, because he was looking in bedrooms, in drawers and things like that where people are going to keep their clothing, their bibles, their you know, simple jewelry. So again not saying she's lying at all, I'm sure she's The likelihood of her lying is slim to non. I doubt she's lying, But I don't think that her saying that it's completely impossible is realistic. Now, because there's always a way, you know, where they that's saying goes, you know, where there's a will, there's a way. So could he have done this? Could he have broken in? Could he have been looking for things and nobody saw him. Yes, could you know be the absolute opposite where he walked in. But again, if he walked in, he probably would not have made it to her bedroom if somebody had seen him prior to that exactly.

32:50 And he's there's physical evidence proving he made it to her bedroom at the very least. So Johnny was ultimately found guilty of murder, and during the sentencing hearing, characternesses were brought up to speak, such as Johnny's mother who made a plea on his behalf and spoke of his good relationship with his siblings. Neighbors were called and spoke of his bad reputation in the neighborhood and how he had been aggressive in the past, although what specifically they mean by that, they don't know. That wasn't specified in the court records that I read. As far as I know, he had never been in trouble with the law. Maybe he was just a nuisance to his neighbors kind of thing. And officers were also called up who worked at the Potter County Jail who said that Johnny was very well behaved and hadn't caused any trouble during his time in custody during the course of the trial. In addition, not once during any part of the trial did any other psychiatrists or experts that deemed him to be both mentally impaired and chronically psychotic ever testify, Nor did anyone bring up the abuse that attributed to his instability.

33:59 Why wouldn't his defence attorney bring up the doctors that had seen him? It seems like that would be the first thing. If he's getting all of these doctors' reports saying that this very young man is suffering from this, that, and the other thing, why wouldn't you bring that up in trial? Well, according to Johnny, in a letter that he had written to the news, he had written like a letter to the editor to various newspapers and different media outlets, basically saying that I did not want this man to be my lawyer. There were two men that I wanted to be my lawyer. One was a good friend of my mom's. One was a good friend of the family.

34:42 And the police officers told me no, I had to have Vegi Colius. Eugi Colius works for them, he doesn't work for me. I would think that would cause some sort of a mistrial to begin with if the attorney, if he feels the attorney is not working for him but working for the secution. I fully agree. But then you also had that letter that BG Collius wrote. You know, there it seemed like he was very much, you know, looking out for Johnny's best interest at the same time, based on the fact that this very clear indicator of his mental instability and the trauma he went through being a contributing factor not being admitted as evidence, the jury never heard about it.

35:24 That doesn't look like he's got his best interest. At heart from that, I would say. Now, Now, Johnny, according to court records, was sentenced to death and an appeal for a habeas release was immediately filed. He was represented by a different attorney after his case concluded. Now a stay of execution was granted pending an evidentiary hearing where the sentence for death was reinstated and ordered to be conducted on October thirtieth, nineteen eighty seven. Then another stay was ordered pending appeal. Johnny appealed to his conviction numerous times, all for the same reason quote. By destroying potentially exculpatory evidence to state denied him a fair trial and deprived him of due process of law. Now, this appeal was in reference to the DNA evidence recovered during sister Tada's autopsy that doctor Erdmund himself said he discarded. However, according to court records, quote, after doctor Erdman found external evidence of a rape, he injected saline solution into the vaginal vaults and recovered a small quantity of fluid. From these vaginal washings, doctor Erdmann tested for the presence of sperm and prostrate secretions and found both. In addition to these tests, doctor Erdman used the entire vaginal content sample he recovered from sister Bends's body. So they're saying in the court records he used that the entire sample, But according to the same exact document, literally the same one quote, no test was conducted from the vaginal contents designed to

36:55 determine the assailant's blood type. So either he had enough to conduct a test that he just didn't perform, or he used up everything. But either way he got rid of it. Either way he got rid of it. So he had But if he got rid of it, then that, at least to me, implies that he had enough to do all of the testing that he needed to do. That's what I'm saying. And again we're gonna talk about doctor Erdman. I'm not done with him. Not done, Okay, so we're all going to wait for the other shoe to drop because we I know she's got way more things to say about this he do. So there's also the issue that much of the evidence gathered at the scene was not used in court, so the jury never heard about it. This included footprints that did not belong to Johnny, a bloody shirt found in her room that didn't belong to him, a saw that didn't belong to him, as well as the fingerprints found at the scene that we're from an unknown person, as well as black hairs because Johnny's fingerprints only for a matched two fingerprints, one on the butter knife, one on the headboard. That's it.

38:04 I'm really trying to wrap my head around this, that this young man did not get a fair trial in any way, shape or form. You have all of this evidence. Now, you can't hide evidence, no from a defense attorney. You also can't hide it from the jury. Well that's true, but you you can't hide it initially from the defense attorney. Okay, there's like this whole transparency thing, and I says, the evidence we're going to use, Okay, Lea, let's send it over to the defense attorney because they can't be surprised. It's not it's not allowed.

38:44 No, exactly, it's not allowed at all. But also, and I'm not saying if he's guilty, he's guilty, but he needs a fair trial, and this is not fair. If they only found two of his fingerprints, and every other piece of evidence shirt, the bloody shirt, the hair, or the everything doesn't match him, why would you even why would they even proceed with a trial if there is evidence that does not. Match exactly now. Additionally, according to the blog post from the Skeptical jerm And, I'm hesitant to his blog posts and things like this, but you very well thought out, and what they're saying matches what I read in court documents and all of that. Based on this blog post, a fourteen year old boy had been interviewed and he claimed that he had been with Johnny when Johnny said he broke into the cont two days prior to the murder.

39:39 But of course that an interview was conducted outside of court. The jury never heard about it. No one ever heard about it. Then, of course you have the issue that the police absolutely believed that the same person who killed sister Tadia killed by Narnie Bryson, But when Johnny was arrested, they never once asked him about Narnie's murder, which doesn't make sense to me. You were so convinced that the same person committed both attacks, but you only ask the person that you were insisting killed one. You're not asking about the other's. It sounds like there's some serious Shannigan's going on here, And why isn't It seems like to me, why isn't anybody in this young man's corner fighting for him? You know, his attorney's supposed to do that. They have all this other evidence that I would say lends to some serious doubt on whether he murdered this nun, And you're not saying, well, why isn't you know we're gonna if you're not gonna bring this evidence up, I'm gonna bring this evidence up.

40:42 I mean, you can't put two and two together and get five. So why isn't anybody in this young man's corner going, hey, you have a bloody shirt doesn't match his? Did you test the blood on the shirt. Is it a match to his blood type? You have hairs that you found that don't belong to the sister and don't belong to him. Where did they come from? Why isn't anybody questioning all of this other evidence? Why isn't anybody testing any of this other evidence? Yes he had there were two fingerprints that belonged to him. Did they find any other fingerprints that didn't belong to him?

41:23 Yes? They did. Why isn't anybody saying that this is what I'm saying. You find all of these all of this other evidence, but nobody's bothering to say, hey, wait a minute, what's going on here? And now you have a young man that is on death row for a crime he may or may not have committed, but it lends some serious doubt to the validity of their case. So Johnny's appeal was denied once again, and he's awaiting execution. He's still writing his letters, and during the year spent on death row, many people start advocating for Johnny and asking for him to be granted clemency, so much so that Governor Ann Richards granted him a thirty day stay of execution an hour before his set execution date of January seventh, nineteen ninety two. These calls for clemency came directly from Amnesty International, Pope John Paul's Second, the Franciscan Sisters of Mary Immaculate of Amarillo, and the Bishops of Texas.

42:27 In the Bishops of Texas statement, they said, quote, in the case of Johnny Frank Garrett, we believe that the court should take into consideration not only the fact that he was a juvenile at the time of the crime, but also that there is evidence not admitted in the previous court proceedings that he had separate brain damage, was abused as a child, and was addicted to drugs. He is now diagnosed as chronically psychotic and as the International, in their statements said, quote in light of the medical evidence of this case, referring to the abuse suffered by Johnny as a child, and the determination from a psychologist that interviewed him in nineteen eighty eight, who said that Johnny's case was one of the most virulent histories of abuse and neglect that he had ever encountered in over twenty eight years of practice. Amnesty International is concerned that Johnny Garrett's execution would be in violation of the United Nations Economic and Social Council resolution adopted in May of nineteen eighty nine, which recommends eliminating the death penalty for persons suffering from mental impairment or extremely limited mental competence.

43:28 The little side note, how did they get all of How did they hear all about this evidence that wasn't used in trial? Like the bishops and whatnot? Who told them? Yes? I a psychiatrist had come out in nineteen eighty eight saying that he was chronically psychotic and severely abused. An appeal for clemency was made three times leading up to his execution, but the Supreme Court denied everyone, including the one made an hour before his new execution time. According to The New York Times, hearing had been inducted by the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles to determine if Johnny's sentence should be commuted to life, but the board voted by seventeen to zero with one abstention, for the death sentence to stand. So on February eleventh, nineteen ninety two, Johnny Frank Garrett was put to death by a lethal injection. His last meal was ice cream, and his last words were allegedly quote, I'd like to thank my family for loving me and taking care of me.

44:25 The rest of the world can kiss my ass. And I say allegedly because while this is widely regarded as his last words, they were never officially recorded, even though it was very strange because they usually last statements are recorded. But I looked on the like the Texas Department of Corrections for their death row inmates, everyone that had been put to death, it showed like if they had a last meal, what it was and what their last words were. And his last words were blank. So again there's serious doubt as to what was said. Oh what he. Said, Yes it but like I said, it is widely regarded that that is what he said. Now, this is not where the story ends. A lot of things occurred in the years after Johnny's execution, one of which was doctor Lph Erdman, the pathologist who didn't test the DNA evidence, ended up in a lot of trouble, which put a lot of the cases he assisted in in question. In nineteen ninety two, Erdmund was indicted on charges for falsifying an autopsy and accusations that he performed made to order autopsies for police. This sent defense attorneys into a frenzy looking to see if his work led to false convictions.

45:36 According to the La Times, many prosecutors over the years had actually questioned doctor Erdman's bore habits and like literally someone said he didn't know his left from his right, like he was a mess, but they continued to utilize his expertise in court. At least twenty three of his cases in forty one counties were under review and bodies were exhumed to have them examined. Former Dallas County medical Examiner Linda Norton said, quote Erdmand routinely performs made to order autopsies that support a police version of a story. Some of Erdman's findings are so wrong as to be an insult to the intelligence of an average human being. It came out during this investigation that Erdman had lied about a variety of things during the conduction of different autopsies, including the weighing of a spleen and gallbladder of a man who after speaking with the family, it was learned that this man had those organs removed years before his death.

46:33 He had also charged the county for an autopsy that pending an investigation was determined never happened, like they exumed the body and there were no incisions. Can't perform an autopsy unless you're cutting into somebody. But they continued to use this doctor. Well not after this. No, but prior to come on. Somebody had to have some sort of serious doubt on what he was doing prior to this time. Well, no one said anything. It was also learned that his wife had been receiving a lot of money from tissue and bone samples that came from the body's erdmin had autopsy that she was sending for donations, like she was sending them to body farms and stuff for research, and they were paying her when she wasn't ethically receiving these tissue samples and bones and things like that. It was also learns that he had lost the head of a murder victim. The murder victim had been shot in the head. He was supposed to send this head out for analysis or maybe even to extract the bullet, and he lost it, which led to the accused killer walking on the charges. Because no one to this day knows what happened to the head or how it was lost in the first place. And in fact he had turned up a body bones after like eight months of the police department, who are or the prosecution or whoever, going like, where's the body? We need the body and he goes, oh, no, here it is and the head that he put with

48:04 the body belonged to a child or a young teenager. Because he didn't have the head. Nobody is saying, well, you have some serious issues here, like what is going on? And in response to all that, he did have his license revoked, big whoop, and he wasn't jailed, and I believe he had to pay a fine. His response was that people make mistakes. Seems like he's making mistakes or he made mistakes pretty frequently. Now, even though Erdmann was clearly making these massive mistakes, if you can call them them, and everyone knew it, no one bothered to take a second look at Johnny's case. Posthumously, it went it's fine. The pathologist that had basically the the evidence that sealed the deal quote unquote, even though it was never properly tested, has had his license from him for his unethical work and doing things in favor of the prosecution and the police. But you know, we're not going to look at the case that caused a seventeen year old to be put to death. We're not going to do that. Then, in two thousand and three, Potter County authorities re submitted the DNA evidence from Narnie Bryson, and they got a hint. The DNA belonged to Cuban refugee fifty five year old Leoncio Perez Roeda, who was on parole in New Mexico. Now Leonzio was this same exact man that police had arrested for peeping two weeks

49:37 after Narnie's murder. Same guy. Additionally, the black hairs that were found at both scenes were confirmed to belong to Rueda, who it was learned, was friends with Fernando Flores, the man that police initially believed to have been Sister Toda's killer. At the time of Sister to DIA's murder, Leoncio was living with a Catholic family and receiving assistance Catholic family Services, which if you remember that professor said he believed that the person that committed these murders was not a native of Amarillo and had ties to Catholicism, whether they themselves were Catholic or not. He believed they were, but they had ties to Catholicism now. Leoncio also allegedly had been in contact with Sister Toda prior to the murder. Five months after his arrest, Leoncio spoke to Jesse Quackenbush, who was an attorney hired to clear Johnny's name by his family, and Leonsio told Jesse that he had sexually assaulted a nun at the orders of Fernando Flores. In fact, he did it to both women on Fernando's orders. However, Leoncio was only ever charged with one murder, that of Narnie Bryson, and he received forty five years in prison after taking a plea deal with the possibility of parole.

50:58 And what happened to the other murder, they just said, oh, well, we've already executed somebody, so we don't have to do anything else with that. Yeah. Based on all of this, it's clear that Johnny Frank Garrett was put to death by some for something he probably didn't do. There is a theory that the clairvoyant made up the story about seeing Johnny in a vision because the police didn't have any leads and they used Johnny as a scapegoat because he was allegedly he was allegedly seen by a police officer the day before the murder beating a bush with a bat in the front yard, So I don't know if the police looked at him, and when he looks like he's trouble, we'll just blame it on him kind of thing. They just happened to kind of get lucky that he had reconnenced the convent. There's clearly a lot of misconducts and while Leoncio allegedly confessed sister to do his murder, the State of Taxes is not going to go back on the stance they've taken regarding Johnny. They made a big show of having their killer, even though they said from the very beginning that they believed one person was responsible both for both murders, and this person was a Keepan descent.

52:03 There is a partition asking for a posthumist exoneration started by Johnny's sisters, and I hope that they get it. This case was just, i'll stay wrong from the get go, and nobody wants to take responsibility for all of the errors, all of the i'll say misconduct by the Medical Examiner's office. Him in particular, but nobody wants to take responsibility for that. They don't want to say, you know, we made a mistake, and we're sorry for the mistake that we made. What are they afraid of a lawsuit? You know? Is that the reasoning behind this. But you have another person that claimed or confessed to murdering both women, but you're not going to do anything about it.

52:53 I don't think they want to admit they were wrong, and they cut corners to get an answer. It was from the prosecution side. It was wrong from the defense's side because all of this other evidence was never introduced. All of the doctors that had seen this young man and clearly said that he was suffering with all sorts of mental issues because of you know, the child abuse and the drug addiction and all of that. Both sides were wrong, and yet nobody's going to say, you know, we messed up. We shouldn't have done this, We should have been looking for the real killer, and this young man was put to death because it seems to me like they wanted an easy out.

53:44 I think they did. I think they fully wanted an easy out. Say, look look at what we did. We found the murderer, but she did really, and this young man and his family have suffered because of the mistakes that were blatantly obvious and should have never happened. Absolutely, Like, it's rare, as I said, for me to cover a case where I doubts of an accused accused person's guilt. But it's even more rare for me to stumble upon a case like not actively searching for it where the accused is so clearly innocent. Once you start to dig a little deeper, because when you look at this case at face value, you just look at the court records and things like that, it's he obviously did it.

54:27 But then you start digging and you realize, no, no, he didn't. None of this makes sense. None of it makes sense. Jesse Quackenbush actually made a like a documentary called The Last Word, and it's about Johnny's trial, about basically fighting for exoneration after the fact. There was also a movie that was needed. It's a horror movie. It's called Johnny Frank Garrett's Last Word and basically in the movie, Johnny Frank Garrett is put to death for murdering sister Tada Bens. They didn't change any of that, They just added that you he comes or his spirit has cursed the town and is going after everyone that lied. Basically a trial, which after the fact, looking back that that's quite satisfying to think about. But he didn't do it.

55:13 He didn't do it. I there were I won't die on a lot of hills, but this is the hill I will die on. I blame you because it this would be something that would be, you know, like you want to jump on the bandwagon for you want to you know, stand on the soapbox and with the megaphone start screaming. The petition will be in the source notes who can sign it, also posted on Instagram, and it'll be on our website. But yeah, this this, this was this was this was a case. This was a full rabbit hole kind of case. For me. It wasn't supposed to be this long, It wasn't supposed to be this involved. And then I kept going and I realized that none of it made any sort of sense. And the website, there's a couple of websites that I believe are affiliated with Jesse Quackenbush, or at least the documentary that has the letters, the letters that Johnny wrote, the letter from his lawyer and the call for clemency from the Amnesty International and the Bishops of Texas will also be in the source notes.

56:23 But thank you everyone for being here to listen to this very very sad Halloween chapter the Book of the Dead. Have a lovely rest of your week. Emily will be back with another probably horrible rabbit hole that you'll take us all down. Yes, we will see you all next time in another chapter of the Book of the Dead. Bye, guys, thank you so much for listening to this chapter of the Book of the Dead, and don't forget that you can always connect with us on Instagram, you can connect with us on Twitter, and you can absolutely connect with us on Patreon. We also have a merch store as well that we have frequent discount codes coming out for so that you guys can get March hand drawn by myself at a better cost.

57:14 We hope you have a lovely rest of your week, and just remember, please be kind. And don't forget to always stay safe, stay curious, and stay vigilant. Bye guys, Bye,