Novela 7-Hell Hath No Fury-The Betty Broderick Story w/ Love and Murder Podcast
In today's episode, we bring you a guest episode from Love and Murder: Heartbreak to Homicide. Ky brings you the infamous Betty Broderick case, a story of love, betrayal, and murder. Betty, a once-devoted wife and mother, found herself at the center...
In today's episode, we bring you a guest episode from Love and Murder: Heartbreak to Homicide. Ky brings you the infamous Betty Broderick case, a story of love, betrayal, and murder. Betty, a once-devoted wife and mother, found herself at the center of a scandalous double homicide after her bitter divorce from her ex-husband, Dan Broderick, and his new wife, Linda Kolkena. Raised in a strict Catholic household, Betty's life took a dark turn as her marriage crumbled, leading to years of resentment, emotional trauma, and ultimately, the murders.
Ky examines the events that pushed Betty to the edge, from her tumultuous relationship with Dan to the psychological and emotional toll that came with their separation. Was Betty driven to murder by Dan’s infidelity and manipulation, or was she a cold, calculated killer? Tune in and decide for yourself: Was Betty a victim or a villain? Share your thoughts in the comments below and visit Love and Murder for more true crime stories of love that turned to homicide.
www.murderandlove.com
0:00 Now part of the dark Cast Network. Welcome to indie podcasts with a dark side. In today's episode, we talk about a case of the love turned to hatred, marriage dissolved and to revenge, and a double homicide that has been. Debated over for decades. By the end of this episode, I'll ask you to be the judge. We're talking about the case of Betting Broderick. Right now on Love and. Murder, Welcome, Welcome, everyone, Welcome, Old Lambs, Welcome New Lambs too.
0:49 Love and Murder your weekly true crime podcast telling you of relationships that turned to homicide. I am your host, Kai, and in today's episode, I'm asking you to be the judge. We are talking about a case that throughout the years, people haven't decided if this person is guilty or not. Before we begin, I want to say I apologize for the background noise because I know you can hear my fan so I apologize. But it's hot. I tried to do this recording without it on and I almost roasted to death. I also want to remind you that this episode and all my episodes are sponsored by my Lambsanpatreon, Patreon, dot com Forward Slash Love and Murder. If you want. Episodes that don't have intros, don't have commercials, get right into the meat of the episode, then join our Patreon.
1:35 We also have some very interesting bonus episodes coming out this month, like the case of Angela Simota. So if you want more true crime episodes, more chiens, and to be a supporter of Love and Murder, join us over in Patreon. Patreon dot com forward slash Love and Murder now without further ado, grab your butts, grab your BJ's applejuice, Murder and Love dot com forward slash bjs and let's get into this Love and Murder. Elizabeth and Biseglia, also known as Betty, was born in Bronxville, New York, on November seventh, nineteen forty seven. She was actually the third child of six children to parents Marita and Frank Bisseglia. Frank, her father, owned a very successful plaster in business, which was able to provide for his a large family. The family, coming from an Irish, American and Italian background, were also Catholics who ran a very strict household and expected obedience and high standards from their children. Coming from that background, Betty was raised to be a traditional wife.
2:42 They didn't really raise her. According to Betty, they didn't really raise her to go to school, be a businesswoman. They raised her to be a traditional wife and support her husband. And I guess they did that with the rest of the girls and the boys. They raised them to be quote traditional men. Quote, go to Catholic schools. Be careful with dating until you find a Catholic man, support him while he works. Be blessed in your later years with beautiful grandchildren. End quote. This was a quote from Betty herself. She went to Maria Regina High School in Hartstille, New York, and was able to graduate in nineteen sixty five. After high school, she went to college, the College of Mount Saint Vincent in the Bronx, where she was able to do an accelerated program and got a degree in teaching for early childhood education with a minor in English. Now, while she was in college, one night she did go to a dance at a different college. She and her friends went over to the University of Notre Dame and this was in nineteen sixty five. This is the same year she was going to graduate. This is where she met Dan Broderick now Daniel T.
3:53 Broderick. The third was born in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. He was the oldest child, the oldest son of a very large Irish Catholic family, so he has the Irish American background and the Catholic background, so he had a similar upbringing to Betty. When he met Betty, he was a twenty one year old medical student and at that time she was seventeen. They began talking at the dance and continued talking thereafter, and their relationship quickly progressed. Four years later, they actually got married on April twelfth. Nineteen sixty nine. Quote. Dan never once wavered from his goal of making me his wife. He would wait, he would do and say whatever was necessary, even agreeing with me when he didn't, and doing things I wanted to do and he didn't until he had me.
4:41 Nobody ever used the terms obsessive, compulsive or stalker back then, but that's what he was. A Short time after they were married, Betty became pregnant with their first child, Kim, who was then born in nineteen seventy. After Kim was born, Dan completed his MD and then he decided that that's. Not all I want to do. I want to combine this medical degree with a law degree, so he enrolled in Harvard Law School and was accepted. Also after the wedding, according to Betty, Dan became very controlling. Quote. He took charge of the bank books and my paychecks, and I more or less had to do what he said.
5:23 While all this is going on, Dan and Betty were also quickly having even more children, four to be exact. So they already have Kim, who was born in nineteen seventy Then they had another daughter, Lee, who was born in nineteen seventy one. They had a son named Daniel born in nineteen seventy six, and they had a son named Rhett born in nineteen seventy nine. They did have another unnamed baby, but this baby died four days after they were born. According to Betty, she was pregnant nine times during her marriage to Dan. She said Dan didn't allow her to use birth control. She said, in addition to the children that she currently has and the one who died, she also had two miscarriages and two abortions.
6:09 Then after her last child died, she got her tubes tiedes because she just couldn't take it anymore and she didn't want to be pregnant anymore. Also, after her last child died, she said this was the first time she tried to commit suicide. Quote, I felt totally trapped with Dan and cut off from my family. I just wanted to escape from it all and die. I was twenty three and I couldn't face decades more of this existence. And in addition to this instance of trying to take her life, she says there was another time when she did try to take her life as well. While all this is going on, Dan is still in school. Betty is actually the main provider for the family. He's going to school on a student loan, but you still need to be able to eat, feed all the children that you're having, and everything like that. Betty was the one working and providing for the family while Dan went to school.
7:04 After Dan graduated, he was quickly hired by a law firm in San Diego, California, and so he uprooted his family and moved over to San Diego to be able to work at this law firm, helping to now provide for his family. While he started this job, Betty continued working part time and she was selling tupperware and doing avon on the side. While she's continuing to support Dan and raising the children. So far, during the marriage, the couple constantly fought, and Betty usually threatened to leave Dan, and Dan would be like, go whatever. He just ignored her for the most part. So Dan worked as a medical malpractice attorney for that law firm in San Diego for three years, and in nineteen seventy eight he started his own law firm and started earning almost one million dollars a year. So that's one million dollars a year in nineteen seventy eight. And I did some math. Well I actually went to Google. I didn't actually do the math, but I did some math quote unquote, and figured out what one million dollars back then would be today, and it would be four point eight million dollars. So this dude started his own business and started pulling in four point eight million dollars a year. So now it's time for easy living, right Your wife supported you all through two schoolings, had all these kids for you, and was
8:36 basically the backbone in you being able to make four point eight million dollars, So now it's just time for the happiness to roll in, right. Well, the marriage between Betty and Dan was quickly coming apart, Betty started to suspecting Dan of having an affear, especially when in the fall of nineteen eighty two, he hired a legal assistant who was a twenty one year old woman. Twenty one year old Linda Colkana had been a Delta Airlines flight attendance where she quit that job and wanted to find something new to do with her life, which is how she got this position of a legal assistant. Betty said she started suspecting an affair after she evesdropped on a conversation where they were at a celebration for the business and he heard Dan call in Linda quote studying. I mean, I don't think if I heard my husband call a woman studying, I'd be.
9:33 Like, oh my god, you're having an affair because he thinks she's beautiful. I mean, the only thing that would make me make that jump to an affair is that he got her phone number or social media or whatever people are doing these days. But just because he called her beautiful, I mean, people are beautiful. There's people more beautiful than me. I'm keenly aware of that. That's okay. Anyways, When she kept accusing him of having an affair, he would constantly say that he's not having an affair, and when Betty told him to fire Linda, he said, no, I'm not firing her. So Betty said, quote that female had nothing on me. I'm prettier, smarter, classier. She is a dumb, uneducated tramp with no heritage or schooling or talent.
10:23 He'll get over her and come back to me. Well, even with that mentality, she continued to accuse Dan of cheating on her, and by October nineteen eighty three, you can see that the marriage was really really crumbling. Well by November twenty second, nineteen eighty three, which was Dan's birthday, Betty couldn't take it anymore. What happened was she went to his business to surprise him for his birthday, only to discover that him and Linda had left for the day. Quote. I waited until like five, She's waiting for him to come back. While she's at the office, she's looking at and she noticed there were remnants of a party, meaning they had an office party.
11:05 Quote. And that's after I saw the refrigerator and my wedding crystal in all this imported wine and the stereo and his photograph on Linda's table. The funny thing was it was a picture of him taken before we had been married. So when she saw all that, she just lost it. She went home, grabbed all of Dan's clothes, doused it in gasoline, and burned them in her backyard. She had a weight in to exhale moment. Now, I do want to clarify something for you. A lot of this information about their early life comes from Betty's words, So it actually comes from her memoir, which is called Betty Broderick Tellin On Myself. I want to make that abundantly clear because in the last week, out.
11:51 Of all this time I've been doing this podcast, in. The last week, I've had like two people accuse me of making stuff up in my episodes. And as all my lambs know, well the old ones, all my old lambs know, I don't make anything up. I research research, research, and I retell you what I researched. And if I make anything up, I let it be abundantly clear. I'll tell you like, oh, that's how I imagined it in my head or whatever. But I don't make anything up. What would be the sense in that then I'm not actually giving you an accurate case, so you can form your opinions on what would be the sense in me making anything up. So also, the second reason I wanted to let you know where the information from the earliest parts of their life is coming from is because I'm letting you know that we're only getting one side of the story. We're only getting Betty's side of the story of how the marriage was, how it dissolved, and everything like that. So I just wanted you to understand that all the early life before the trial, all of that comes from Betty's memoir. So just wanted to make that clear.
13:02 So after this happened, the couple separated in February of nineteen eighty five. Dan moved out, but Betty didn't want him to, but he was like, I can't take this anymore, and he moved out. But then again, on Betty's side, if you were so tired of all the stuff he's put you through, especially since you're saying that he's cheating on you, wouldn't you want him to move out? This is just my thoughts. Anyway, he moved out and then he filed for divorce later on in nineteen eighty five. According to Betty, throughout the divorce, Dan used his legal expertise to manipulate proceedings, manipulate custody arrangements, manipulate financial arrangements, and shield his assets.
13:45 He moved into the family home. Betty wasn't allowed to be in the family home, but he was allowed to move back in and he managed to gain full custody of their children. But this little tidbit. He he got full custody of the children only after Betty would leave them on his doorstep one by one. So I guess she would be like, Oh, you don't want me to have, you know, spousal support. Take this child. Oh you left me for this wench, take this child, you know, like one of those. But maybe she did it out of anger. But it helped the case and he was able to get custody of the children. But according to Betty, through his manipulation, he was able to get access to the children. He restricted her access to the children, He restricted her access to financial resources, and left her isolated. So basically she just felt like she was by herself. While all this is happening, Linda moved into the family home and joined Dan. Let's take a brief pause for a commercial break and If you don't like the commercial breaks, you could also join on Patreon dot com, Forward Slash, Love and Murder.
14:57 They have no commercials over there. Hey, lambs, I'm I want. To share something game changing with you because I believe in it and use it myself. Simply Safe Security System. With Simply Safe, you get twenty four to seven whole home protection. Every window, room and door is covered against intruders, fires, water damage, and even medical emergencies. And the best part is it's all monitored by professionals ready to dispatch police at a moment's notice. Now you know I don't recommend brands that I don't use myself. Simply Safe is the real deal. Use my link Murderinlove dot com, Forward Slash Simply Save fifty that's simply with an I Safe five zero and you'll get fifty percent off a new system, plus a free camera. Professional monitoring for under one dollars a day with your first month free, no contracts, no cancelation fees, Easy to install yourself or choose the optional pro install plus a sixty day money backgap guarantee with free return shipping, no problems. Murderanlove dot com Forward Slash simply with an I Safe five zero. When you visit the site, they'll help you find a perfect security system tailored for you, and you can even buy now, pay later with a firm protect what matters most with simply Safe.
16:22 Go to Murderinlove dot com forward slash simply with an I Safe five zero and get started today. Also for ease of access, link is in the show notes below Simply Safe Advanced Security, Complete peace of mind. And before we get back to the show, I want to remind you of saving money with BJS. As you well know, I use BJ's myself, and I want to bring these savings to you. Whenever I go grocery shopping at any other store and they give me that total for bread and eggs one hundred dollars, I'm like, are you are you? Are you kidding me? Right now? When I signed up to BJ's now three years ago, I was just doing it just as a test to see if it was worth it, and it was. Because I'm still with them three years later, and I want to pass these savings onto you. Murderinlove dot com Ford slash BJS to get thirty five dollars off your first year's membership. Not only do you get that thirty five dollars off, but you get into a club that saves you money on groceries, and in addition to those savings, you get amazing coupons every month to help you save even more. So join me in saving money and join BJS today Murderinlove dot com Forward slash BJ's to get thirty five dollars off your first year's membership. Links are in the show notes below. Join today, save tomorrow, and now back to the show. Now, I'm not saying that he was definitely having an affair with her. It could be possible that he just had his eye on her.
17:48 Maybe later on it could have turned to an affair. But this opportunity arose that. You know, he's leaving his wife and now he can be with Linda. Or he could have totally been having an affair. I don't know his side of the story. So this is leaving Betty feeling like she's going crazy. She's angry, she's frustrated, she's alone, and she started acting out. She started vandalizing Dan's property, she started making threats to Dan and his woman. She's claiming that Dan's making it hard for her to find a lawyer. Because he's a respected lawyer. Might have had making four point eight million dollars a year.
18:28 Nobody wanted to contest him, So nobody wanted to take her on as a client, according to her, and represent her in a divorce goring against mister Dan Broderick. Are you serious? No? I no, Maybe you should find another lawyer. She also says, like I said before, she also believed and she's telling lawyers that Dan is using his influence in the legal community to win custody sole custody of their children. He's also selling the house, even though she doesn't want him to sell the house, and if he does sell the house, he's not going to give her her fear share of the sale profit. I don't know about all of that, but my question is, how are you saying that he used his manipulation to win sole custody of the children when you left them one by one on his door. So, just based on that information, I don't think he used his manipulation to get the kids.
19:25 I think you left the kids. For whatever reason, you know, frustration, anger, whatever. I think you left your kids. And he pointed that out to the judge, and the judge agreed that that wasn't a stable household for the kids to be in, so they need to be with their father. This is just my opinion based on the information that I was given. So four years after Dan filed for divorce in nineteen eighty nine, the divorce was finalized. After the divorce was finalized, Betty's emotional health took a nosedive. She started to act more raund. She started leaving hundreds of messages on Dan's answering machine, cussing him out, cussing his wife out, which prompted Dan to then put a restrain in order against her. He actually had multiple restraining orders against her, which she would continuously ignore. She tore up areas of the house. She even one time drove her car through his front door, even though at the time that she did that, her children were inside the house. Dan, on the other side, tried to control Betty, or maintain control over Betty by every time she did something like, for instance, if she didn't listen to the restrain in order and she showed up, he wouldn't give her support payments. So, okay, you weren't supposed to come within five hundred feet of the house, yet here you are, so this month, I'm not giving you your two thousand dollars check, you know, stuff like that.
20:56 So in addition to docking her payments, he would all send her letters, like legal letters. Saying cease and desist. And whatever other legal jargon you can say, to leave me the frick alone and stop doing that. All this in legal jargon, and even one time he had her temporarily admitted to a mental health institution. Betty described how she felt in going to court with Dan in these words quote It's as if you're putting a housewife in the ring with Muhammad Ali. That's how she felt. I think with everything going on, Betty was like, really, she's really coming apart mentally. She feels like she's being manipulated.
21:40 She feels like she was replaced, she feels like she has no one in her corner. And I also have a kind of I have an idea of why this all is happening, but I'll save that to the end and i'll see if y'all agree with me. On April twenty. Second, nineteen eighty nine, Dan and Linda got married. Linda was so worried about Betty coming too her wedding and doing something crazy that she was pushing Dan to wear a bulletproof vest to their wedding because she thought, you know, because clearly she thought Betty would come and show up and shoot Dan or whatever. So she was trying to get him to wear bulletproof vest. But he didn't and Betty.
22:23 Didn't show up at all. After the wedding, though, Betty would tell everybody that Linda had started mailing her facial cream and slimming ads, like, you know, telling her she's old and she's fat, here's you know, stuff like that. She also said that Linda would start taunting her and stuff like that. But my thing is, why start that after the wedding? Wouldn't you do that before the wedding? But you know, maybe it could happen. It could happen. I'm not saying it didn't. Then, on November fifth, nineteen eighty nine, at around five thirty am, Betty showed up at Dan's house. She used the key that she had taken from Kim to enter the house and walked around the house, probably making herself even more angry. This should be mine and this should be mine. I'm the one who put him through college.
23:10 Da da da Da da da and When she got to Dan and Linda's bedroom, she saw them sleeping together. That's when she fired five shots with a thirty eight caliber revolver that she had just bought a month after Dan married Linda. Linda was hit twice in the neck and chest, killing her instantly, and Dan was injured when he was shot and the bullet fractured her rib penetrated his right lung. One bullet hit the wall and one bullet hit a nightstand. Dan was shot in this way because at this time he was reaching for the phone, and when Betty saw that, she ripped the phones out of the wall to stop anybody from calling for help.
23:57 When this incident occurred, Betty was two days away from turning forty two, Dan was seventeen days away from turning forty five, and Linda was twenty eight years old. After this incident, she ran from the house, so police officers arrived at the scene to find two people fatally shot. They found Linda on the edge of the bed and Dan on the floor, both of them dead. Because police knew of the divorce, they knew of the multiple restraining orders and everything that was going on with this family. The first person they thought of who could do this was Betty. Now Betty. After she ran from the house, she called her daughter Lee, Lee and her boyfriend answered the phone and spoke to Betty, calmed her down, everything like that, and Betty later surrendered to police. When she was brought into an interrogation room, she did admit that she pulled the trigger, but she said she didn't mean to kill him. I didn't go over there to kill them. I just I wanted to talk to Dan, ask him what was wrong? Why did you leave me? Blah blah blah, And then I was going to commit suicide in front of him. I was not planning on going over there and committed murder. So police arrested her and charged her with two counts of murder.
25:15 So if convicted of these two counts of murder, she could actually face a life in prison without the possibility of parole. She pled not guilty and was held without bail in the Las Colina's jail. Now, when this case went to trial, it actually happened in two separate trials, and we're going to get into that. Criminal defense attorney Jack Eely represented Betty, and Carrie Wells was the prosecutor for the state of California. Betty's defense was that she was a battered wife. She said over the years, Dan had basically driven her crazy through physical, mental abuse and psychological abuse. She said he would manipulate everything. He would gaslight her whatever, whatever, and make her question her perception of something happened, her memory, and just her sanity on a whole quote, no one has the right to take the life of another human being. However, Dan's consistent lies, minimizations, and calling Betty crazy fueled a lot of the animus in their relationship. Dan's constant denials of an affair escalated Betty's pre existent narcissistic personality, disorder and a need for order.
26:36 They pointed out that although Betty would do things to then like throw things at him, talk bad about him to other people, lock him out of the house, and I guess ultimately kill him, this was because of her loss of control and she just couldn't take it anymore, which to me, that's a weak defense because she didn't have control. She did all these things to this man, and he was supposed to just take it like that's a week defense. He did what any rational human being would do, which is to leave. According to her, defense. She did not go to that house with the premeditated idea to murder anyone.
27:21 So basically your honor. To be charged with first degree murder, you have to have that idea of premeditated killing. But she did not have that idea. She only wanted to go to the house to confront him and then kill herself. Then they presented evidence showing that Betty was suicidal. There was a letter that she sent to her divorce lawyer and that was in her own handwriting, that was a week. Before the murders. That said, quote, I can't stand this anymore. Constant threats of court, jail, contempt finds, etc. Which is very scary to me. No matter what the evidence, I always lose. And then another part of the letter says, quote them always insinuating I'm crazy. So this is just showing that, you know, she's slowly losing it. Well, the prosecution portrayed her as a premeditated murderer. They pointed out her calculated actions leading up to the crime. They even had her boyfriend take the stand. Yes, throughout all of this she had a boyfriend. Me personally, I thought she was alone because she said she was isolated. She was alone, everything like that she had a boyfriend, Bradley t Wright.
28:36 Bradley said they began dating in nineteen eighty five, and nineteen eighty five is when Dan filed for divorce, So you had a boyfriend this whole time. Well, he took the stan and he was actually a prosecution witness. And note that he's still with Betty even after she committed murder. He still stayed there and supported her even though he's testifying against her. Anyways, he took the stand and he did say that she was suicidal, and he described flash marks and scarring that Betty had all over her left arm, and they even had Betty hold out her arm for the jurors to see that she had these slash marks. Even though he is a prosecution witness, the prosecution still came back and said that all of this talk of suicide and the suicide attempts were more for show and not actual evidence of suicide attempts. And interestingly enough, it was actually Bradley who found the bodies of Dan and Linda.
29:38 He told the court that he had spent the night with Betty and when he woke up he saw she was gone and that the phone was ringing. When he picked up the phone, one of Betty's friends was on the phone and she said, look, Bradley, you have to go to Dan's house right now and make sure that everything over there is okay. So he jumped in his car, drove over to the house, and when he got to the house, he's the one who found the bodies, the bloody murder scene and everything like that, and he's the one who called the cops. He also testified that although she was suicidal, and although he was still in a relationship with her after she murdered her ex husband and she's going through a murder trial and he's vegan for the prosecution. Anyways, even after all of that, he did say that she did often speak of her hatred of Dan, and she did often talk about her desire to kill him and Linda. So I do want to point out that in doing the research and some publications it said he spoke of her being suicidal and in others he spoke of her desire to kill them. They never put the two in the same articles, So I didn't say that he spoke of her being suicidal and he spoke of her hatred for them. It was in different publications that I read each one, so I just put it together and I said, he said she was suicidal, and he spoke of his desire to kill them, So I did want to point that out. Doctor Ruth Roth, who
31:08 was the psychologist who tried to mediate the resolution between Daniel and Betty, who was the psychologist's mediator over the custody battle with Daniel and Betty. Testified at the trial. She said that Betty didn't suffer from mental disorders. Instead, she said, quote, I think she was angry. She said Betty told her that she threatened her ex husband quote all the time. In March of nineteen eighty seven, she interviewed both Betty and Dan while trying to get them to agree in a custody arrangement for their children so that they wouldn't have to go to court. She also said that although Betty was the one who kept dropping the kids off at Dan's house, she would come back and said that she wanted custody of the children.
31:55 Then at other times. She would randomly come out and say that if Dan would get her custody of the children, she would refuse it. So it was like, which one do you want? She also testified that by late nineteen eighty nine, Dan was actually considering returning custody of the two younger boys to Betty, but when she had her meetings with doctor Ross alone, Betty refused to discuss custody matters. She would just go off on a tangent, and, as doctor Roth said, quote started off on her own agenda. Doctor Roth also testified to the court that on March third, nineteen eighty seven, Betty said, quote, I'm not going to be a single parent of four kids.
32:37 He'll die first. In that same session, she also said quote the less I see them or hear from them, the better. No bother, no kids. Doctor Ross told the court that when she heard these comments coming from Betty, she decided to go against the client doctor privacy privilege, and she ended up telling Dan what Betty had said. Now, she didn't break the law. Because if there is a threat made against her person, the law does allow you to breach that patient client confidentiality rule. She also said that on March twelfth, nineteen eighty seven, Betty repeated her comments again, saying quote, no way, I'm going to be a single mother with four kids.
33:25 He'll die first. I'm not letting go that easy. The little bitch was mine, He'll stay mine. This is what she said. So she said this twice. So doctor Roth decided to ask her point blank if this was a threat, and she responded with quote, I threatened a bitch. All the time. Then Sylvia Cavins took the stand. She was Daniel's housekeeper from December nineteen eighty seven to November nineteen eighty nine. She's testified that she heard Betty threaten him three different times. Well, I'm gonna say this. She heard her threaten him all the time, but three times that she considered real. She said the spring that Dan and Linda were married, Betty threatened to put quote four bullets in Dan's head, one for each of the kids. So when she said that, the defense said, oh, got you there. Why when the police asked you about the threat, why did you say that Betty planned to shoot him three times, not four?
34:28 And the housekeeper said, quote, I must have meant four, which, again another weak argument. Got you there? When the police questioned you said that she said she was going to shoot him three times. Now on the stand, you're saying four. What does it matter. The point is she said she was going to shoot him, doesn't matter if it was one, three, five, eighteen, like, are you serious? That was your defense. She also said shortly after she started working for Dan, that's when she started hearing Betty threaten in him. One of those threats that happened shortly after she started working was when Betty said, quote, she would kill Dan. This was like right after she started working. So then she tried to diffuse the situation.
35:11 Really not really because she doesn't know this woman, so she's not really taking it seriously. So she said, quote, oh great, he'd be dead and you'd either be dead or in prison, and the children would be orphans. And in response to that, Betty said that would not be a problem because a jury, when it found out what Dan did to me, would let me off. That's what she told the housekeeper, and so the housekeeper responded with, quote, I wouldn't count on that. Then the prosecution had forensic psychiatrists and criminologists take the stand. This was doctor park Diet and he actually used the analysis of doctor Melvin Goldsband, who actually worked on the case for the prosecution, and he used that analysis and brought it to the court.
35:57 D It said that. Betty had a history ironic and narcissistic personality, and he read from doctor Goldsband's notes that said Betty did have this kind of personality and that she was quote severely narcissistic and histeronic. Basically, your honor, They said, she has an inflated sense of self importance and a need to be the center of attention. So, after all that was brought before the court, brought before the jury, and everything like that, the trial ended in a hung jury with two jurors wanted to go for manslaughter because they said there was a lack of intent there for a first degree murder charge, so they couldn't come to a unanimous agreement, and it ended in a hung jury. Well, the trial started again later that year with the same defense attorney, same prosecutor, literally the same trial. Everything went how it had before, and on December eleventh, nineteen ninety one, the jury came back with a guilty verdict of two counts of second degree murder. Betty was sentenced to two consecutive terms of fifteen years to life plus two years for illegal use of a firearm. This was the maximum sentence under the law at that time. Keep in mind that even though she was just now found guilty. She had still been in jail since nineteen eighty nine since the murder,
37:29 so she started serving her sentence at the California Institute. For Women in Chino, California. Then, in January twenty ten, she requested parole a legend exclusion of crucial evidence by the presiding judge. Her defense argued that this could have influenced the jury's decision, so please grant us parole. The judge denied this parole because they said that she did not show remorse or even acknowledge her wrongdoing. She again tried to get parole in November twenty eleven January twenty seventeen, and each time she was denied. She actually won't be eligible for parole again until January of twenty thirty two. By that time, she'll be eighty four. Currently she is in prison. She's still in the same prison, and she's currently working in various aspects of the prison, like scheduling for the mental health unit.
38:26 She's doing janitorial work, and she reportedly enjoys doing everything that she's doing in prison. She's actually described as a model citizen. Now, one day somebody found letters from Betty to Bradley. These letters dated from two thousand and three to two thousand and six, and it showed that even after she was sentenced, Bradley was still sending her money. Bradley, after these letters were found, said that he wished these letters were never discovered, which were in his storage locker. What happened was he quit paying rent to the storage facility, and then the stuff in there were auctioned off, which if you know you're not able to make the rent, take your stuff out. I don't know. I'm not gonna judge.
39:15 I don't know what was going on. In his life. He could maybe he couldn't afford to get a truck. Maybe he didn't have friends with a truck. He couldn't get his stuff out of the locker. Who am I to judge? He said? Quote For me personally, it's just like reopening a sore womb that I've tried after all this time to sort of fade away. I don't know why the American public is always so excited about these kinds of things. Well, Bradley, I know on my part, I'm not excited about it. What I take from true crime is understanding the mentality. For me, it's a psychological thing, understanding the mentality of people who do these things. Why are you doing these things?
39:55 Which I haven't come to an understanding of it, and I guess I never will because I'm not somebody. Who would do this these things. So it's more of trying to psychologically understand people as well as hearing things that people would do that I wouldn't have even thought could have been. Like, it just makes me more aware, and I bring these stories out to make other people more aware of what could possibly happen in the world, and maybe if somebody was thinking about doing the same thing, helping them make a different decision. That's what my true crime is about. So that's to answer what you're saying, Bradley, if you ever hear this. So in the letters, Betty talked about her love for Bradley and everything like that, stuff she should have thought about before she was murdering her husband, because she had been with Bradley when he divorced her when he filed the petition to divorce nineteen eighty five. So maybe before you ruin the kid's life, you should have thought about your love for Bradley, not while you're in prison and after as everything is done. In one letter from All two thousand and six, she said, quote, if I had a penny for every time I think of you, I'd be a millionaire many times over again. That should have happened before you took drastic action. In another one, she said, quote, I was thinking of what I'm looking for in a man since you're not available. Well, the list was a description of you. You're exactly the guy. Damn it again, when you had him, you wasn't thinking like that.
41:25 If he's such the perfect. Man, you shouldn't have been obsessing over another man, which I know the other man was your ex husband, but still, if your ex husband was so terrible and horrible towards you and you found the perfect man, shouldn't you have just moved on? And I guess from that comment Bradley had already moved on. And so in another letter, she's trying to get him to leave who he's with and sneak away with her and visit her in prison. Like, woman, you're in prison, what can he do? You're literally in prison for the rest of his life. You want him to leave the woman that's with him, who actually physically acts like he is the perfect man, and leave this person to come to prison to visit you. Quote, if you want to live in Laplaiah with me like you say you do, going back to Lisa is not how it's going to happen. I can't believe you don't come here.
42:21 It's been years. Now that she's back to work, maybe you can sneak away. I think she may have these mental health disorders that those doctors said, because even though she had a man, when Dan had a woman, she couldn't fact, she just couldn't take that. Now that Dan's out of the way, and I use that term not Crassley, but now that he's gone, now she's focused on Bradley, even though she already had Bradley, but now Bradley has another woman. So now it's like, oh, put your focus back on me. What are you doing? Leave her? And I wonder if she was out, if she would they'll take in those same drastic measures that she did with Dan. In another letter, she said, quote, sorry to hear your life is a mess. I don't want to come back to a mess.
43:09 Come back. Did you go to counseling? Whatever patterns you will have will continue for better or worse. You know the definition of insanity, doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result. I should know. I'm really glad she said that, because I was about to say, are you serious right now? Because you're literally you were in counseling, you didn't take the counselor's advice, and you were the definition of insanity. But I guess she knew that, and she just I don't know. In other letters, she's continuously begging Bradley for money and for attention and everything like that. And actually have all of the letters, the pictures of the letters in my Patreon, as well as the receipts for the money, so you can go to Patreon dot com Forward Slash Love and Murder.
43:55 That's part of the extras that I do add to every case. If they're pictures, if they're video, which this case has a video of her daughter testifying in court, so videos, pictures, court documents, all of that is also in the Patreon. This happens for any episode, and that's part of the extra bonuses. My exclusive lambs get Patreon dot com Forward Slash Love and Murder. Currently, Bradley is married and has completely moved on with his life, and you know he's not looking back on Betty. Quote, so much time has elapsed right now. So this revelation that there were some letters from Betty to me that surfaced out of nowhere, I mean, so what this is what he said? Now, Betty and Dan's kids, of course, are adults. Now.
44:43 Kim and her brothers, Dan and Rhett are all married with children. They all have girls. Well, as far as the last recording of what's going on with them, they all had girls, and they apparently visit her in prison. The reason why I know that is because there was a picture of her, her kids, and her grandkids in prison. When Betty was arrested, Kim was nineteen, Lee was eighteen, Daniel was thirteen, and Rhett was ten. Rhett actually did an interview with Oprah, and Betty had done an interview with Oprah also from prison earlier. So Oprah did an interview with Betty first and then she did an interview with Rhtt and Rhett said on the interview with Oprah that he wasn't surprised by his mom's actions at all.
45:28 Quote. I just remember thinking, Wow, I wasn't really surprised. On multiple occasions, my brother and I went to my dad and said to him that we wanted to live with my mom and that not having her kids was driving her crazy and that she could do something extremely irrational if she. Didn't have us. After his mom was arrested, Rhett and Daniel moved in with Kathy Broderick, which is their uncle Larry Broderick's ex wife, out in Colorado. Rhett then explained that the years following were reallyotic. He was going between relatives and going between boot camp for troubled teens. Quote. I constantly felt like I was under the microscope, like everything I did they were trying to blame on my parents' situation. And I guess, you know, that could have made him even more angry, like I'm doing this because of me, not because of the you know, I understand, and I'm not trying to speak for him. I'm just speculating here. That could have just made him even more angry and made him lash out more. That you're not seeing him for him, You're seeing him for what happened to his parents. Later on, Lee had also reported that her father had written out of his will because she was going through a troubled time. She was having problems with school, problems with drugs, and he had written her out of his will. In his will, he had said that the Broaderick estate would be divided equally among his three other kids, and Lee wasn't part of that. I really hope that maybe the civil gave her something. Now
47:02 her children are divided on whether or not she should be released. Lee and Rhett thinks that she should be let out, while Dan and Kim thinks that she should be left in. Again, their thought process might have changed by now, but as of the last reporting. This is what they thought. Lee actually had gone to one of her parole hearings and said that she had a room prepared for her mother. Quote should she ever be able to live her later life outside of the prison walls. During the interview with Oprah, Rhett said, quote keeping her in prison isn't really helping her. She's not a danger to society. The only two people she was a danger to are dead. Dan said that he felt that his mother should remain in prison. Quote in my heart, I know my mother is a good person, but along the way she got lost. Releasing a lost person into society could be a dangerous mistake. And Kim had actually testified against her mother's release, and I do have that video in the Patreon Patreon dot com Ford Slash Love and Murder Now Betty's actions and trials has been the subject of several books, several documentaries, several TV movies, and people still talk about this case to this day, and it's this episode. There's actually a Netflix movie out there called Dirty John The Betty broader Rick Story. I haven't watched it though, but you know, I wanted to tell you that there is a movie out there. Some
48:34 things that I brought to you in this whole episode was not in the movie. This is what I've read because I read about the movie and it said that XYZ wasn't in the movie. So I mean, it's just a loose movie, and you know how they dramatize everything, so it might not even be completely believable. But anyway, there's that movie, Dirty John The Betty broader Rick Story. But I wanted to ask you what do you think think about the case of Betty Broderick. Like in the middle of the episode, I was telling you that I would bring you my thoughts, and what I think is that with all these pregnancies and losing babies, abortions, everything, with all these pregnancies period. I really believe that she had a depressive episode that was not being treated, because remember, once you get pregnant, your body starts getting flooded with hormones.
49:29 When that pregnancy is over, the hormones are flooding out of you, which then which then can change the chemistry of your brain. And with everything that was going on at that time, back to back to back to back pregnancies, and you know, she's feeling like she's the only one making money dealing with all these children. Dan not really looking at the situation and just focusing on his studies and everything. It could be. That she was going through postpartum depression that wasn't treated that then turned into something else, and especially the baby dying, having two abortions miscarriages that can wreck havoc on a person.
50:12 And I really think this is what happened. I really think she was having some mental issues dealing with all those births that was not being diagnosed, that was not being taken seriously, and that was not being looked at. That's what I think. Am I giving her an excuse for murder? No, I'm not, but I'm thinking that's what was going on. So what do you think? Do you think she's a victim of circumstance or do you think she's a cold blooded killer who was actually unremorseful for her actions? As the parole board said, as the psychologist said. What do you think? So I'm gonna go ahead and put out a pole.
50:54 That question is going to be too long for the Spotify pole because they only give me a certain number of characters. So I'm going to figure out how to shorten that question. But that's the gist of it. Do you think she's a victim of circumstance or do you think she's a cold blooded killer? Do you think she premeditated this murder or do you think she actually went in there to commit suicide but then she just saw what was going on and just got angry and then committed murder. So I want to hear from you. I'm going to have that poll question out. Don't forget. I also have the WhatsApp if you want to answer the polls into WhatsApp, Murderinlove, dot Com, Forward Slash WhatsApp. You can also answer it by joining Patreon. You can answer it in the Facebook group, or you can answer it on Spotify. These are all the places that you can answer this poll question, or you could just leave me a comment below in whatever platform you're on, and.
51:46 That is all I have for you today. I want to remind you that a free and easy way to help out love and murder is by simply sharing this episode. So go ahead and share this episode with your mom and your friend and share it to Reddit because we're sharing it with everyone we know and everyone we don't. And as I leave you at the end of every full episode, I want to remind you that it is fit with me now, all love and no murder, y'all. I'll see you in the next episode. Bye. Oh, don't forget to stay tuned for my commercial guests.
52:42 I'm done and I'm cool and Scottish Marchers is a true crime podcast dedicated to people from or living in Scotland. Just like anywhere else in the world, these murders can be truly horrific and shocking and we want to shine more light upon them. Join us every two weeks on Scottish Marchers, where will bring you cases both solved and unsolved, giving you an insight into the other side of Bonnie Scotland. Find us wherever you stream your podcasts, as well as on social media. Join us there bye.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed