Chapter 93: A New York Mystery-The Murder of Bani Yelverton
In today's chapter, we dive into the murder of a woman that history seems to have forgotten. Not anymore. In December of 1969, Bani Yelverton, a young Black woman with a promising future in modeling, was found murdered in her friend's New York...
In today's chapter, we dive into the murder of a woman that history seems to have forgotten. Not anymore. In December of 1969, Bani Yelverton, a young Black woman with a promising future in modeling, was found murdered in her friend's New York apartment under circumstances that baffled investigators. With no sign of forced entry, few concrete leads, and a city gripped by upheaval, the case soon went cold. Who wanted Bani dead—and why?
Connect with us on Social Media!
You can find us at:
Patreon: The Book of the Dead Podcast
Instagram: @bookofthedeadpod
X: @bkofthedeadpod
Facebook: The Book of the Dead Podcast
TikTok: Bookofthedeadpod
Or visit our website at www.botdpod.com
Featuring a promo for True Crime California
True Crime California is a podcast about crimes that take place in, you guessed it - the great Golden State of California. Brought to you by Cindy, a former host of Twisted Listers Podcast, these stories will cover everything from well known crimes we've all heard about, to more obscure stories that need to be told. Join in weekly for new cases, with occasional multi-episode arcs for the bigger cases out there, with mini episodes coming soon too! This podcast is creepy, interesting, and all California, all the time.
Listen here
Bani Autopsy: Sex Assault. (1970, January 9). The Daily News, 54.Cafe Owner is Charged in Model’s Death. (1970, January 18). Daily News, 38.Company, L. T. (2023, December 17). “We’re now part of his flock”: Father Divine - Lantern Theater Company: Searchlight - Medium. Medium. https://medium.com/lantern-theater-company-searchlight/were-now-part-of-his-flock-father-divine-69bb65cb981eJohnson V. City of New York. (1975). In Case Text (No. 71 Civ. 763.). United States District Court. https://casetext.com/case/johnson-v-city-of-new-york-2/Nab Cafe Man in Model’s Killing. (1970, January 18). The Daily News, 4.Papers of Ophelia DeVore, “black is beautiful” pioneer, come to Emory | Emory University | Atlanta GA. (n.d.). Emory University. https://news.emory.edu/stories/2013/05/upress_ophelia_deVore_papers/index.htmlSepia Model Murder, 1969: The Slaying of Bani Yelverton. (2024, July 17). CrimeReads. https://crimereads.com/sepia-model-murder-1969-the-slaying-of-bani-yelverton/Village Restauranteur Arraigned. (1970, January 18). The Sunday Record, 3-A.Woman Murdered in Greenwich Village. (1970, January 9). The Buffalo News, 61.
0:00 Hi guys. I'm Courtney and I'm Lisa, and welcome to the next chapter in the Book of the Dead, brought to you by dark Cast Network indie Podcasts with a Twist. Hi everyone, I'm Cindy, the host of True Crime California, a weekly podcast about murders and other true crime that takes place in the great Golden State. Join me every week as I talk about a new case, some very well known and others not so well known, but always coming straight out of California. True Crime California is a proud member of the dark Cast Network.
1:00 Hello, Hello, Welcome to the next chapter of the Book of the Dead. While looking around for cases to cover, I stumbled upon crime rates dot com, which is a website I have never used for my research, and while perusing it, I came across an article covering a murder that I had never heard of. While researching this case, I realize that there are very few people that have heard of it or this victim. This is the murder of a young black woman, a model making a name for herself in an era and industry that catered to white people, and the publications that did showcase women of color tended to feature lighter skinned models. A beautiful woman with her deep, rich skin tone and soulful eyes was making a name for herself in the industry and was on her way to becoming a household name before all she worked for was ripped away. This is the murder of Bonnie Yelverton. Barbara Yelverton was born in Savannah, Georgia, to Beatrice and Aaron Yelverton, on March eleventh, nineteen thirty two.
2:12 Now not very much is known at all about her childhood, but when she was a child, her parents moved to the family to Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, to join the International Peace Mission, which was led by a man who called himself Father Divine. Father Divine himself is a little bit of an enigma. There's some ambiguity surrounding who he is. He was possibly born George Baker in either Rockville, Maryland, or somewhere in Georgia, maybe in eighteen seventy six. What is known is that he was a major religious figure during the twentieth century, and his full moniker was Reverend Major Jealous Divine, also known as the Messenger. His congregation was a conglomeration of very religious groups like evangelicalism and pentecostalism, mixed with a newer concept for the time called new Thought. The New Thought was a movement where people believed they could change or alter their reality and circumstances entirely due to positive thinking.
3:18 I suppose you could compare it a bit too manifestation. As an additional bit of background on Father Divine, he moved his ministry from Sayerville to Harlem, before ultimately settling in Philadelphia in nineteen forty to escape financial and legal troubles. Some say that he was crazy and a cult leader. He was very strict in his rules for his followers. He placed a heavy emphasis on celibacy even between married couples, and no one was permitted to drink, smoke, or engage in any kind of vulgarity. He also maintained a strict dress code, proclaimed he was an incarnation of God, changed his followers' names, and threatened divine retribution against anyone who defied him. On the flip side, though he was also considered to be a civil rights hero, he advocated heavily for desegregation, implementing it within his ministry, and was vocal in protesting lynching. He provided nourishing and reasonably priced food to his followers as well as the community, and even gave it away to those in need. During the depression, he advocated for communal living and resource pooling, and provided work training and jobs to the community. He was also a big supporter and owner of many small businesses, mostly black owned, that focused on providing reasonably priced, in high quality goods to community members. Now Aaron Yelverton eventually became
4:49 a preacher with this ministry. In the nineteen fifties, with two dollars to call her own, Barbera struck out on her own with dreams of being a model. She was just a teenager. Now. I'm not sure what her parents thought about her going out on her own into the world, but regardless of whether they were okay with it or not, Barbara did leave. She changed her name to Bonnie and headed for New York to make her dreams come true. For a while, she stayed with friends, relatives, and in hotel rooms before signing on with Grace del Marco modeling agency in Harlem. Grace del Marco, according to Emory University, was founded by the model Ophelia Devoor and four other friends in nineteen forty six, and the agency worked to encourage the media to quote portray African Americans in non stereotypical ways. While Bonnie was definitely shorter than what would be considered the model standard at only five foot six, she had quote a distinctive brown skinned, beauty, spelt body, and haunting eyes that would get her inside a few doors, according to crimereads dot com. In nineteen fifty six, she moved into an apartment in the East Village with other tenants involved in the arts, and she started booking jobs.
6:12 In nineteen fifty seven, she appeared on the album cover for New Orleans Blues, and she was part of a campaign for photographer Erwin Blumenfeld in Look magazine. She was the only non white model in the spread, standing out at the end of a row of five women in a lavender dress and blue eyeshadow. She was paid about forty dollars an hour for the shoot, which in today's economy would have been around four hundred and forty seven dollars, so not too bad really for a day's work. The small bio attached to the shoot for Bonnie would say, quote Bonnie's looks and personality embody, the charms, sadness and compassion of a blue singer. While this shoot should have been something to catapult her onto the map, the modeling industry was not kind to black models. Publications like Vogue, Harper's Bazaar, and Vanity Fair cater to white people, and it would be another nine years before England featured a black woman on the cover of their edition of Vogue, featuring Donielle Luna in March of nineteen sixty six, and it would be seventeen years before America got with the program and featured Beverly Johnson in the August nineteen seventy four edition. In nineteen fifty eight, Bonnie was featured on another album cover, and she modeled for three days in a live window ad for a Harlem department store. New York Age columnist Clyde Reid wrote of the ad quote for three days, one of New York's top Sepia models adorned Bloomstein's window on West one twenty fifth Street in
7:45 a demonstration for a mattress. Incidentally, she looked lovely in bedroom slippers. In addition to her modeling work, Bonnie was working other odd jobs to supplement her income. She worked with a friend that sold customs jewelry and learned how to make and sell her own, and she did waitress jobs at the village itch on Hudson Street. Bonnie was known to surround herself with beauty in her daily life and among her friend group she spent a lot of time going out with them to various bars and restaurants. However, Bonnie was fairly private. She didn't share much about herself and never brought anyone to her apartment, which she grew increasingly reluctant to return to. She lived on the fourth floor, and while it had started out nice, the neighborhood began to change and decline as drugs made their way in.
8:37 Some shady characters began hanging around, and there were a few break ins, so she usually came home just to shower and change her clothes, opting to sleep elsewhere. In December of nineteen sixty nine, Bonnie is thirty five years old and is staying at her friend Jack Frolick's apartment while he is out of the country in Haiti for a vacation. Jack's apartment was a luxury three hundred dollars a month unit at one Washington Square Village. According to the Daily News, a far cry from Bonnie's small apartment on the Lower east Side. Jack and Bonnie had known each other for about six years at this point, and she was the perfect person to house sit for him, especially while she was having her apartment redone. On January sixth, nineteen seventy, Jack returns to Manhattan from his trip and heads to his apartment. When he gets to the eleventh floor, he's surprised that the apartment is very chilly. It's about twenty degrees outside, so for a window to be left open is strange. He soon notices the balcony door was left open, and feet away, to his horror is Bonnie's body, face down on the living room floor. She was nude except for a pair of underwear around her ankles. The Buffalo News reported that her throat had been cut and there was a clear sign of a struggle throughout the apartment.
9:59 Bloodstains to be found all over the room, on the walls, floor, and furniture. According to court records, police while processing the scene recovered red ceramic particles from her parent clothing, matching the pieces of two red ceramic pots that had been found in the apartment. Doctor Elliot Gross, associate medical examiner, performed the autopsy the next day, and he determined that she had been severely beaten and stabbed in the neck before the cut of her throat. He also confirmed that sexual assault had taken place. Doctor Gross determined that Bonnie had been dead for nine days upon her discovery, meaning that her date of death was sometime on the twenty eighth of December. During the police investigation, detectives pretty quickly determined that Bonnie knew her attacker detected. Charles Zambrie told the Daily News quote she was known not to associate with strangers. Police interviewed Bonnie's friends, one of which was a man named Robert W. Johnson. He was forty six years old and the owner of the Village Itch where Bonnie worked as a waitress. He was actually interviewed twice, once on January seventh, the day after the discovery of Bonnie's murder, and on January sixteenth, nine days later. He told them that he had known Bonnie for about six years and she worked a shift on December twenty seventh.
11:27 Around that same time, Bonnie had told Robert he could stay at her apartment as she was staying at Jack's because, according to the Daily News, Robert had recently lost his and was currently separated from his wife. He temporarily moved into Bonnie's apartment and brought some clothing with him. Court records confirmed that Robert and Bonnie had worked together at the village Itch on the twenty seventh, and they leapt together early in the morning on the twenty eighth. They shared a cab to sixth Avenue, where they separated and Robert had it to her apartment on Third Street alone. He claims that that was the last time he saw her. However, according to those same court records, Robert also positively identified a pair of shoes belonging to him that were found at Bonnie's apartment. On the soles of these shoes were particles of bread ceramic, which the medical examiner concluded came from the same face as the particles found on Bonnie.
12:28 Police also determined that Robert had been lying about where he had been. Later on in the day of December twenty eighth, Robert claimed that he had stopped at a specific store to pick up some ingredients for the restaurant, but when police looked into this, they found that the shop had been closed for the whole day. Additionally, Robert had been subjected to a polygraph test, which he failed after positively identifying the shoes as his. Robert was arrested for Bonnie's murder on January sixteenth. One month later, on February seventeenth, the grand jury declined an indictment and the charges were dismissed. Robert was free to go, and I couldn't tell you why. My only assumption is that maybe the particles weren't enough to prove that he was the one to murder Bonnie. As far as I could tell, they never found the knife used, and even if there was DNA from the sexual assault, they were a very long way of being able to properly test it. To this day, no one else has ever been arrested for Bonnie's murder, and her case remains unsolved. Now. Robert did end upsuing the City of New York, citing damages and alleging false imprisonment and malicious persecution. This was actually ruled in favor of New York on the basis that the courts found Robert's argument baseless. Quote. A distinct and essential
13:59 element of the cause of action is malice, which must be proved as an independent fact in order for the claimant to sustain his action. Plaintiff's proof here completely lacks even a suggestion of improper motive by the police or prosecutors in arresting and attempted to indict him. The plaintiff argues that defendants have not shown any motive for the murder, and emphasizes that the grand jury did not return an indictment against him. However, the law does not require that defendants prove motive, only reasonable cause for arrest, and certainly the fact that plaintiff was not indicted does not establish false arrest and imprisonment. We add that the plaintiff's testimony at trial was weak, shabby, and totally unconvincing. So in essence, the courts determined that there was no malice, there was no false imprisonment, They had probable cause to place him under arrest, and they also did not need a motive to arrest him. Now, as for whether I think he's guilty, I think it's certainly possible. The particles on his shoes proved that he was in the apartment either during or write after the murder, and he didn't have an alibi However, to my knowledge, as I said, they never found the knife used, and they couldn't determine a motive as to why he would kill her. It's possible that maybe he made an advancement towards her and Bonnie rejected him given the sexual assault, or it could have been from some
15:31 other reason. Considering police were led to him pretty quickly also makes me believe that there's definitely a chance that he could be guilty. They just didn't have enough evidence to support that. Now, Bonnie Elverton was a vibrant and beautiful woman and very cautious. I just don't see a stranger doing this, and I covered her case because I think it's terrible that so few people know about her. There's only a hand full of mentions about her in the papers, and the only real information I could get besides the one court record from the suit and the articles mentioning her murder and Robert's arrest was the Crime Breeds article. She deserved better than that, So today, remember Bonnie.
16:20 Thank you guys so much for listening to this chapter of the Book of the Dead. I know it's on the shorter side. I would compare it to a mini episode, but Bonnie's story deserve to be told. Her loved ones that are still alive, deserve for other people to remember her, and they deserve justice. I think it's ridiculous that after so many decades there's never been another arrest, and if Robert is guilty, he got away with it. I wish there was more information out there so I could tell you about who she was as a person, but there was no real in on who she was, if she had siblings, I just don't know, and I wish I did so that you can get the full picture of just exactly who Bonnie Elverton was. But on our Instagram you can see in the pictures that I found of some of her photo shoots, including the one that she did for Irwin and Look magazine. As always, I hope you have a wonderful week and I will see you in the next chapter of the Book of the Dead. Bye, guys, thank you.
17:34 So much for listening to this chapter of the Book of the Dead, and don't forget that you can always connect with us on Instagram, you can connect with us on Twitter, and you can absolutely connect with us on Patreon. We also have a merchore as well that we have frequent discount codes coming out for so that you guys can get March hand drawn by myself at a better cost. We hope you have a lovely rest of your week and just remember, please be kind and don't forget to always stay safe, stay curious and stay vigilant. Bye guys, Bye,
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed